do I have to refrigerate a pumpkin pie I made tonight? Or can I leave it out?
Are you channeling your best self with this comment? (If you're not sure, check out our Code of Conduct.)
Merrill is a co-founder of Food52.
I'd put it in the fridge -- it's got eggs and dairy in it, I'm guessing?
Kristen is the Creative Director of Food52
It's a custard pie, so you should refrigerate it to be safe. Then just take it out a couple hours before serving tomorrow to come back down to room temperature.
Yes, custard pies are one of the exceptions to the it's-safe-to-leave-baked-goods-unrefrigerated rule. Protein + moisture = Danger
Won't the crust get soggy if I refrigerate? Yes, it does have eggs and heavy cream.
The refrigerator is a drier environment than your kitchen so it won't add to the problem. And you'll cover the pie with plastic wrap so it doesn't absorb stray refrigerator aromas and that will keep any condensation from forming while it comes back to room temperature for service. But, yes, the crust will soften somewhat regardless.
Please enter a valid email address.
Well played. You deserve a cookie.
And how to plan your own menu!
Community Members' Spring Menus
The Scrappy Baking Trick That Takes the Cake (Well, Pie!)
$50 & Under Gifts (Mom-Style)
Springy Asparagus Pesto
Off-the-Beaten-Path Picks for Mom