How many apples do i need to fill a 10-inch pie plate? And what are the best kind of apples for apple pie?

  • Posted by: JessP
  • November 23, 2010
  • 133777 views
  • 8 Comments

7 Comments

Review our Code of Conduct
Don't send me emails about new comments
takeanonion
takeanonion November 23, 2010

4-5 granny smiths

Review our Code of Conduct
Don't send me emails about new comments
beyondcelery
beyondcelery November 23, 2010

For my 9-inch pie, which is about 1 1/2 - 2 inches deep, I use 6 medium apples. For yours, I'd probably do 7 and mound it up and if it didn't seem quite full enough, I'd add 1/2 or 1 more.

My very favorite pie apples are Gravenstein, but they're ripe early in the season and hard to get this time of year. Right now, I'd use a mix of Jonagold and Granny Smith, or Jonagold and Braeburn. You're looking to get a nice balance between sweet and tart, so take a look at the apples available. Fuji or Golden Delicious are nice when you balance them with a very tart apple, like Granny Smith.

Review our Code of Conduct
Don't send me emails about new comments
Sally
Sally November 23, 2010

6 to 8 large apples, I like apples that hold their shape like Cortland, Baldwin, or Northern spy and it's fun to mix tart and sweet. I usually cut my apples and pile them in the pan (before I line it with pastry) to get the right amount. Then I put them in a bowl with the sugar, etc., line the pan with the dough, and pour them back in the pie. They will cook down a little, so I like to pile them in the center 2 to 3 inches above the rim.

Review our Code of Conduct
Don't send me emails about new comments
2nd Generation Baker
2nd Generation Baker November 23, 2011

Sally is the first and only person I've ever seen mention Cortlands and Baldwins in a pie. Much of the web seems to say Cortlands turn to mush and don't make a good pie. Not true! I learned from my mom who's been baking apple pies for 55 years. For some strange reason, Baldwins have fallen out of favor and are very difficult to find. For this year's Thanksgiving pie, we'll be making a 40 minute drive to a farm in Bolton, MA to get Baldwins. That's how committed we are to this combination for the best pie!

cheater chef
cheater chef November 23, 2010

There is just one supermarket in my area that has a convenient, easy to read chart right above the apples that tells what's good for what. Isn't that an easy great idea?

Review our Code of Conduct
Don't send me emails about new comments
mrslarkin
mrslarkin November 23, 2010

10" is pretty big pie pan, so I'd use 8 or so apples. (about 8 cups) Mix them up - I like empire, grannies, goldens, macs, etc. so you get a nice assortment of textures/tastes.

I've heard you can slice your apples ahead, mix them w sugar/flour mixture and let them sit for a while (a few hours?) before placing in pie shell, which is supposed to help reduce the empty-pie-shell syndrome.

Review our Code of Conduct
Don't send me emails about new comments
Jon Palmer
Jon Palmer November 24, 2010

Whatever kind of apples you use, using two or three different varities usually produces a more dynamic and interesting taste.

Review our Code of Conduct
Don't send me emails about new comments
Kate McDermott-Art of the Pie

I take a variety of apples, some for sweet, some for tart, some that hold their shape, some that don't. Pile them in your pie plate/pan until it "looks" right. Then, I chop the apples and put them back in the pan, reserving an apple or so, if I need to add or subtract. Each pie pan will take a different amount. For a 9" Emile Henri deep dish pan or pyrex deep dish 9", I usually find that about 2.5 lbs is about enough. For a 10", probably about 3 lbs. If you do the "pile and look" method, you can just tell by the "look" if it is what you like.

Review our Code of Conduct
Don't send me emails about new comments
Showing 7 out of 7 Comments Back to top
Recommended by Food52