Hi there. I am about to venture into a Julia Child recipe which calls for a 9 inch fire-proof casserole. I have a large Le Creuset an All-Clad Non-stick and a Lodge cast iron Dutch oven. Which can I use?
Are you channeling your best self with this comment? (If you're not sure, check out our Code of Conduct.)
Not sure why you would need fire proof unless your going to cook with a wood fire.
But if this is the case then I wouldn't use either of the posted option. Black cast iron would be my only choice. Your Le creuset could have trouble with the enamel popping off at too high a heat and your non-stick has even lower heat tolerance. But if your just roasting in the oven or going from a burner to the oven then the le creuset would be my choice.
thanks for the response - I should have noted that the recipe requires that you literally "light the dish on fire" after the cognac is stirred in....??????
Well, doing this is a great technique although I've done this more time than I can remember I have never done this with non-stick. Le Creuset. I hope you have good venting with the fan on. The flame and heat should only be momentary.
pierino is a trusted source on General Cooking and Tough Love.
Stay away from non-stick for anything that requires igniting flames. The Le Creuset will work. And as my pal ChefDaddy advises, be sure you have a fan. Indeed the cognac burns off really fast and the flavor is subtle. In old school restaurants this was often done table side by the server or the front of the house guy.
I think by "fire proof" she (Julia) means "something that won't melt". I'm pretty sure you can flamber (the technique in question) in just about anything that you'd normally cook in, but don't try it in say a non-Pyrex glass bowl or a salad bowl or something.
It's a weird way to say it, but I think that is what she means to imply.
If you're non-stick has Teflon, be careful how hot you get it as it isn't meant for high-heat cooking (something about poisons leaching into the food).
Pierino just reminded me of the many catastraphe's I have seen in my day for table side flambe. Besides frightened customers there hve also been burnt cieling tiles, table cloths, and singed hair and clothes as well as the fire department showing up during a 300+ cover saturday night. Woo hoo! You always send out the new guy and never the experienced.
Chris is a trusted source on General Cooking
ChefDaddy, you are a hoot!! As for non-stick coatings, particularly the older ones, I think the concern is more that at high temperatures, they could be volatilized and you could breathe them. The concerns have grown because found in the blood, and we don't really know what their effects might be.
Sort of off topic, but ChefDaddy's experiences reminded me of an essential flamber guideline...never pour the liquor into the pan directly from the bottle. Always measure into a separate vessel first.
If you neglect this guideline...see ChefDaddy's post above. :-/
Ok, now you all have me a bit nervous, but I am doing this "Coq au Vin"! That being said, is my ventilation fan what you are saying I need - check. What purpose will this serve if not just to help with smoke, I presume. Will the flames be high? Do I need to have my husband ready with a fire extinguisher - cuz I can do that...wish me luck =)
I doubt the flames will be to high but there will be a rush of hot air momentarily. Just to exaust the hot air and give the flames a direction to go. Don't be afraid, just turn your fan on ignite the cognac and stand back until flames subside. Have fun!
This IS fun! As you've been instructed measure out your cognac and don't do the Rachael Ray thing (a couple of "glugs"). The technique is actually pretty simple; you tip your pan toward the flame and the alcohol vapor will set in on fire. Don't use a match unless you happen to like the taste of sulphur bits.
Don't worry, pollygirl. If you check my profile, you'll see that I do not have a range hood. While it keeps me from undertaking a lot of smoky techniques and makes dinner odors linger, I don't hesitate to light a little alcohol on fire. Go ahead, and blast away! Just do take Fantastic Mr. Fox's advice, and never pour from the bottle.
never from the bottle and, though this seems obvious, don't lean over the pan while you light it...
One time at band camp...
I did a steak Diane once and the flames caught the oil soaked vent hood above and we had a fire. Clean your vents once in awhile.
Meatballs lend comfort on one family's journey from Mexico.
Albondigas from Oaxaca, Mexico
Where to Eat in Modica, Sicily
What's New in the Neighborhood
30-Minute Chickpea Curry
The Hits Keep Coming