I follow the directions to a tee for a great pecan pie. But it is NEVER fully baked, even if i leave it in 5-10 more minutes. Whats the secret?

Question

I follow the directions to a tee for a great pecan pie.  But it is NEVER fully baked, even if i leave it in 5-10 more minutes.  Whats the secret?

boulangere · Answer

The general rule of pies is that high initial heat sets the bottom crust, so your logic is spot on. Give it 15 minutes at 400, then turn the down for the remainder of the baking time.

Cindi W. · Answer

What are you opinions on starting a pecan pie at 400’ then dropping the temp to 350’?   I read in one of my books that any custard pie needs to bake low and slow...

Cindi W. · Answer

Thanks for your thots.  Helpful!  I’ve been reading several recipes...  the common thread is 350’ for anywhere from 40-60 minutes.  Thats a big range.  Your ideas will help.

boulangere · Answer

Try to cultivate the habit of baking for doneness, not time. I know it sounds odd, but a pecan pie is a custard. The classic definition of a custard is anything which is set by the coagulation of egg protein. Cheesecake, crème brûlée, even pumpkin pie are a few. The doneness test for any custard is when you can bump the edge of the pan, and it just juggles in the center. If it's wiggly or wavy, it isn't done. Baking times are more of a guide than a guarantee. But a jiggle will never let you down.

grandrivergirl · Answer

I wonder if your oven temperature is a little off.

I follow the directions to a tee for a great pecan pie. But it is NEVER fully baked, even if i leave it in 5-10 more minutes. Whats the secret?

5 Comments

Popular on Food52

The Best Vanilla Extract Substitute Is Probably Hiding in Your Kitchen

11 Easy Dinner Recipes for When It's Been a Loooong Week

The 15 Best Pasta Salad Recipes to Make All Summer Long