I believe America's Test Kitchen has an opinion on this subject; I recall watching a video segment on an equipment showdown for this product category. You might be able to track down this video online but I have not bothered to do so.
I have a 2-cup genuine Pyrex® measuring cup. The markings are starting to fade at the bottom of the container but seeing as it's 25+ years old and I stick it in the dishwasher, that's understandable. When people talk about things that last a lifetime, it's often hyperbole but this product is one that might actually outlive me.
I second 702551's recommendation. As I recall from the video there is a PYREX brand and a pyrex brand. One for Europe and the other for US markets. There are 2 different glass formulations used... you want the one made from borosilicate glass as it is tempered to resist shattering from heat. Here is the TV clip, unfortunately it is behind a paywall... https://www.americastestkitchen.com/equipment_reviews/2041-liquid-measuring-cups?incode=MASAD00L0&ref=new_search_experience_1
By sheer coincidence my local PBS station re-aired this America's Test Kitchen episode.
Unsurprisingly their winner was the 1-cup version of the aforementioned Pyrex model (borosilicate glass, $10). ATK's runner-up was the 1-cup OXO Good Grips angled measuring cup (plastic, $7).
Having owned a number of brands, it is clear that not all spouts are created equal and some pour more sloppily than others. I now have three Pyrex measuring cups (1-cup, 2-cup, and 4-cup), all of which were found at estate sales and are still going strong. If I had to choose just one, the 2-cup is the one I most frequently use and is the most versatile, though I’m a big fan of the 4-cup as well as it can double as a mixing bowl for some recipes (thus fewer dishes!). Just wash them by hand to keep the markings from wearing off the side and they should last you for many years.
Choose based on size of what you most oftern measure - it’s not necessary to have every size. (Maybe one large and one small, or two of same size to have one clean while one is in use). Two or three major brands all have good reputations. Only replace if/when cup is nicked or broken, which is rare - they last for years.
5 Comments
I have a 2-cup genuine Pyrex® measuring cup. The markings are starting to fade at the bottom of the container but seeing as it's 25+ years old and I stick it in the dishwasher, that's understandable. When people talk about things that last a lifetime, it's often hyperbole but this product is one that might actually outlive me.
Best of luck with your purchase decision.
Unsurprisingly their winner was the 1-cup version of the aforementioned Pyrex model (borosilicate glass, $10). ATK's runner-up was the 1-cup OXO Good Grips angled measuring cup (plastic, $7).
ATK did not discuss replacement.
Two or three major brands all have good reputations.
Only replace if/when cup is nicked or broken, which is rare - they last for years.