I have to make apple pie filling from scratch, but I have no cornstarch. What else can I used to thicken the filling?

Question

I have to make apple pie filling from scratch, but I have no cornstarch.  What else can I used to thicken the filling?

Flotch · Accepted Answer

I usually toss the apples with all-purpose flour, spices and sugar before baking it in the pastry shell and the flour has always been sufficient to thicken the juices that are extracted from the fruit during baking.

zest I. · Answer

A bit of flour goes a long way in lieu of cornstarch. I was out of cornstarch a few weeks ago and subbed whole wheat flour (just a half tablespoon) in an apple cranberry pie. It was delicious and really added some depth to the flavor of the dish.

foodfighter · Answer

you could use some apple butter in place of some of the sweetener and spices.  It is already on the thick side.

Mr_Vittles · Answer

Any sort of thickener will do in a pinch. AP Flour, corn starch, potato starch, Arrow root, tapioca powder. Just make sure you know the proportions because too much of any thickener can lead to a gummy mess or worse, a blander flavor.

Hilarybee · Answer

I like to use either arrowroot powder or tapioca powder. Both work great as thickeners. I like to use tapioca powder is pies the best- I think it makes a silky filling without any of the lumps of cornstarch.

Verdigris · Answer

Tapioca is another alternative.  The quantities are usually printed on the box.

6 Comments

Popular on Food52

The Best Vanilla Extract Substitute Is Probably Hiding in Your Kitchen

11 Easy Dinner Recipes for When It's Been a Loooong Week

The 15 Best Pasta Salad Recipes to Make All Summer Long