🔕 🔔

My Basket ()

The Piglet2014 / Quarterfinal Round, 2014

Summerland vs. Smoke and Pickles


Anne Quatrano

Get the Book

Smoke and Pickles

Edward Lee

Get the Book

Judged by: Josh Malina

3adef58d 5fe7 4b3a 84ba e510b6f8e244  joshua malina

After graduating from Yale University with a B.A. in theatre, Joshua Malina made his professional acting debut in the Broadway production of Aaron Sorkin’s A Few Good Men. He went on to star as Jeremy Goodwin in the critically-acclaimed television series Sports Night, and later played Will Bailey in Sorkin’s multi-Emmy-winning The West Wing.

Elsewhere in film, Malina appeared in the comedy A View from the Top, with Gwyneth Paltrow and Mike Meyers, In the Line of Fire, opposite Clint Eastwood, and Bulworth, with Warren Beatty and Halle Berry. A co-creator and executive producer of the hit show Celebrity Poker Showdown on Bravo, Malina is also the writer-creator of the Crackle webseries Backwash. For three seasons he played the role of Peter Alpert on the USA series In Plain Sight, and he can be seen in the upcoming films Kings of Badassdom and The Young Kieslowski. He is currently starring as David Rosen in ABC's hit show, Scandal

A longtime fan of food, Malina has eaten at least three meals a day for nearly 48 years.

The Judgment

First an admission: A chef I am not. Until age 30, I hadn’t assembled a meal that didn’t involve a box of Kraft mac and cheese, or the push of a microwave button. That changed in 1997, when my wife -- the lovely Melissa -- got pregnant for the first time, and began asking the oddest question: “Honey, what’s for dinner?” By her second trimester, there was often a follow-up query: “What’s for second dinner?” I had to learn how to cook on the spot, and this I did through a combination of anxious calls to my mom and feverish cookbook consultations.

17 years later, I make the majority of meals for my wife and two kids, though as a cook I remain more enthusiastic than adroit. I continue to read cookbooks, and Melissa has taught me that rather than mere compendia of potential dishes, the best of them can be read and lingered over like a good novel. Anne Stiles Quatrano’s Summerland and Edward Lee’s Smoke and Pickles are two such works. I thoroughly enjoyed my assignment, cooking dishes from each, poring over the gorgeous images, and getting to know a bit about each author’s Southern journey. 

Let’s start with Summerland. Brian Woodcock’s photographs of Anne Quatrano’s food, and the family farm for which the book is named, are sublime. If I were ever to hang a print of a citrus salad with dried olives on my wall, I know where I’d find it. The shots in the book not only made me want to cook this food, they made me want to copy her hippy-chic, quaint-cool aesthetic. This woman has taste.

The book is divided into monthly chapters, emphasizing seasonal ingredients. Quatrano and Lee share a farm-to-table attitude that I appreciate, and though I was a bit too daunted to attempt some of Summerland's more esoteric creations (Stumped by Stump de Noel! Intimidated by Agnolotti!), I enjoyed great success at Thanksgiving with her version of Roast Turkey and Gravy, and her Dry-Fried Green Beans are my new go-to side. The recipes were simple to follow and the results savored by my guests. 

I enjoyed reading about life at the farm in Summerland. The tales of farming, polo matches, quail hunts, and “…a glass trifle bowl filled with crushed ice…studded with crisp D’Avignon radishes,” are so removed from this New York Jew’s life that it felt a bit like discovering a new Lord of the Rings book. Kudos to Quatrano (great title for a song) for including lots of instructions for terrific Southern cocktails. 

If Summerland offers the rustic-yet-refined side of Southern cooking, Edward Lee’s Smoke and Pickles is the taste of the South by way of New York and Korea. I enjoyed reading Lee’s many essays, which illuminate both the recipes he includes and his own personal story. He has a funny, candid voice that I responded to. 

Many of the dishes in Lee’s book were interesting variations of things I’ve made in the past. I’ve prepared a lot of hummus and edamame in my life, but would never have thought to combine the two. Lee’s Edamame Hummus is a quick-to-prepare original that I will make often in the future (minus 1 point for referring to it as a “healthy snack,” rather than a “healthful” one. Tut.). Further kudos are due for the delectable synthesis of Italian and Southern in Lee’s Buttermilk Affogato. After I procured some kosher duck (strangely hard to find in Los Angeles), I was anxious to attempt Lee’s Honey-Glazed Roast Duck. This I did with ease and super-tasty results. 

I notched another big win with Lee’s Perfect Rémoulade, and I can finally cross “cook something with an accent aigu” off my bucket list. This and many of the other recipes in Smoke and Pickles work as basic templates. Missing one or two of the ingredients? No sweat. Swap in something else you find in your cupboard. I like that a lot of the dishes here leave a bit of room for the cook to play around. 

I cooked fewer dishes from Summerland than I did from Smoke and Pickles, which is somewhat telling: The recipes in the latter were somehow more approachable to me -- simpler, less precious, edgier (ingredients for Lee’s Tobacco Cookies include “1 good cigar”). The same adjectives apply to the book as a whole. While Summerland speaks of tartan blankets, mini cloches, and Villeroy & Boch tableware, Smoke and Pickles digs deeper with anecdotes about Lee’s junior high days as a tagger, his adult work with disadvantaged teens, and many of his adventures in between. I can’t fault Anne Stiles Quatrano for concentrating more on the food and less on her own life, but I definitely dug Lee’s essays and stories -- and at night, his was the cookbook I wanted to read in bed. 

And the winner is…

Smoke and Pickles: Recipes and Stories from a New Southern Kitchen

Smoke and Pickles: Recipes and Stories from a New Southern Kitchen

Get the Book

Do you Agree? (72 comments)

23b88974 7a89 4ef5 a567 d442bb75da04  avatar

Are you channeling your best self with this comment?
(If you're not sure, check out our Code of Conduct.)

23b88974 7a89 4ef5 a567 d442bb75da04  avatar
8c98c3fd a431 4ea2 97e4 20e3da713ce7  eda takoyaki cooking

almost 4 years ago edamame2003

wasn't sure how smoke and pickles was going to integrate asian and southern cooking, but it sounds like chef did a good job of it and with some interesting stories. thanks for the review--this will be on reading/cooking list!

E512938f 9155 4b82 ba00 eba0c7125364  stringio

almost 4 years ago Joan Osborne

Lovely review and fun to read. You ended up making me want both of these books.

4be0eac3 6b63 477d 8b32 16320a982ef2  face 1

almost 4 years ago Naomi Manygoats

Well done! Have to say I agree, although both are such nice books!

7a609a50 8972 46ea a6cd e9c209e3d690  img 8592

almost 4 years ago tyrannyofcake

Can't wait to get my hands on Smoke and Pickles. At first I wasn't as enthusiastic, but reading the Piglet reviews has persuaded me.

02f532b3 927e 4f1e b6b5 27f76491daf1  img 0896

almost 4 years ago Annie Berrol

Tut! Who knew the clever and talented Josh Malina was also a foodie, and which such good taste?

11a0646e a9e4 45a0 9e20 e971beb986fc  stringio

almost 4 years ago CamillaMMann

What a fun, well-written review. I'll definitely put this on my list of books to get this year!

89628f77 ebe9 4d15 8db7 477daec6bcb0  mcs

almost 4 years ago mcs3000

Super review. So need to check out both books.

1133cdd2 ef6a 4bb8 987e fd38d64fd484  image

almost 4 years ago Alexandra Holbrook

Beautifully written review! Now I want BOTH books!

Cef49d72 d554 46db a888 e97e0311e08e  cimg0737

almost 4 years ago cookinginvictoria

Really nice, thoughtful, articulate review. I love that Josh read and cooked a number of things from each book, but in the end was swayed by the book that, as a home cook, he found to be the most approachable. I haven't browsed through either of these cookbooks yet, but they each sound like real winners to me. I am happy to see Smoke & Pickles advance. It sounds unusual and really appealing!

23b88974 7a89 4ef5 a567 d442bb75da04  avatar

almost 4 years ago ATG117

Great review. But wondering, why did the duck need to be kosher?

496e7c44 98d9 4eba 99b7 3bc1f865f816  screen shot 2013 04 12 at 12.45.52 pm

almost 4 years ago Lemongrass&Lime

I wondered the same thing then realized Mr. Malina refers to himself as a 'New York Jew' in this review so I presume the duck needed to be kosher for his own benefit and not because the recipe specified it :)

23b88974 7a89 4ef5 a567 d442bb75da04  avatar

almost 4 years ago aargle

I am so enjoying the piglet awards and reading all the reviews (this is my first year and have gone back and read results from previous years). Even though I haven't managed to get my hands on any if these cookbooks I already have a favourite. So glad Smoke and Pickles won. This is a great review as it's written by somebody is a home cook albeit a well known one. I will now be definitely buying this book. By the way I love Scandal.

23b88974 7a89 4ef5 a567 d442bb75da04  avatar

almost 4 years ago Teruska

Love Smoke & Pickles!

92324c6f a8a7 4932 b8ea 156809cc7bae  emfraiche

almost 4 years ago EmFraiche

Smoke and Pickles sounds like it has such personality! Thanks for the great review!

23b88974 7a89 4ef5 a567 d442bb75da04  avatar

almost 4 years ago Brenda G

I was pulling for Summerland. I like Anne's style. 1 good cigar doesn't do it for me.

23b88974 7a89 4ef5 a567 d442bb75da04  avatar

almost 4 years ago Teri.stein

Wonderful review! Smoke and Pickles is really emerging as a contender for the crown.

23b88974 7a89 4ef5 a567 d442bb75da04  avatar

almost 4 years ago nancy o

I was pulling for Summerland, but I can't fault this reveiw - good work!

820467dc d1b2 4071 ae7b d918a3648548  image

almost 4 years ago jamcook

Nicely done review...just hope you're not feeding cigars to the kiddies!

23b88974 7a89 4ef5 a567 d442bb75da04  avatar

almost 4 years ago topdawg11

The book is a really good book, and the reviewer did a great job.

Decc7adc 039b 4ba6 8bd3 c45338b5e0fe  1534845 10202771834757974 1750157774 o

almost 4 years ago Maria Martinez

Without having read either book yet, I do like stories with my food. Smoke and pickles sounds like a winner!

12dce35f 6e8e 443b b7f1 57f89fd8574f  profile

almost 4 years ago Hannah Robie

A sound and well-considered decision. I like the style of this teview and am more inclined to believe him as a result!

Account Created


Logged In


Email Sent

Please check your email for instructions
on how to reset your password

Successfully logged out

Let's Keep in Touch!

Get the recipes and features that have us talking, plus first dibs on events and limited-batch products.

(Oh, and $10 off your order of $50 or more in the Food52 Shop, too.)

Please enter a valid email address.