The Weirdly Comforting Precursor to Cinnamon Toast Crunch

May 10, 2016

By now we have all decided that breakfast is by far the best meal of the day, (right?). And with so many great options out there (French toast! Perfect pancakes! Eggs any which way!), it's become the meal we prefer to eat over any other, regardless of the time of day. And all the spiffy breakfast options out there aside, sometimes all you really want is a solid, dependable, regular bowl of cereal, and that’s okay too.

Cereal is, afterall, the meal that carried us out the door through childhood and the humble dish that holds us over while hunched at our computers during our “adult” years. These days there are cereals out there to cater to almost any taste—nutty riffs on granola for the “health conscious”; heartier, fibrous grains for a more substantial bowl; and marshmallow-dimpled nuggets to call back the kid in us all—and the average American consumes an estimated 10 pounds of the stuff every year.

But cereal hasn’t always been around to ease our empty stomachs or pacify our indecisive palates. Before the nation fell for these familiar flakes, it fell in love with milk toast.

Photo by James Ransom

A popular dish of the 19th century, milk toast is exactly as the name implies: a marriage of two breakfast standbys, milk and toast, resulting in a something that could be considered the precursor to the cereals we fill our bowls and our bellies with today. It was an obsession for many, and was cited as healing almost all ails, but was realistically heralded because it was easy for the sick and elderly to digest. Unsurprisingly, children were also pretty big fans of what was essentially a bready precursor of today's Cinnamon Toast Crunch.

Shop the Story

The recipe is simple: Toast some slices of hearty bread, slather them with butter, crumble into a bowl, and drown them in sweetened milk. If you’re thinking this sounds suspicious and possibly disgusting, you’re not alone. Even given a reasonable measure of breakfast-loving deduction (cereal is always a win and toast is great any time, therefore cereal + toast = brilliant?), I was considerably skeptical about the promise of this old-timey favorite, but willing to investigate in the name of breakfast-related science.

A toast! Photo by James Ransom

As it turns out, eating milk toast is a bit like eating some sort of breakfast bread pudding that’s unusually comforting. Like mac n’ cheese, brownies, and, well, cereal, it’s a mashup of best bites—crusty, charred corners buried among a sea of sweet, warm mush, and a buttery slick of cinnamon-sugar laced milk. It's a little like French toast, and a little like cereal left soaking.

Join The Conversation

Top Comment:
“On shrove Tuesday In Scandinavia we eat a sweet bun topped with sugar crystals and a slice of Marcipan in the middle boiled milk poured over and after bun is soaked and sloppy with drenched milk eat it with gusto! Delicious and warming on a winter's day. ”
— Solveig W.

Milk toast is a meal of solace. It's homey, warm, and earnest. It's the kind of thing that would welcome a new day or round out a particularly difficult evening. Satisfying in its own right, it's easy to see how this combination of bread and sweet milk once served the same niche as a bowl of cereal does today—and how it's worth bringing back.

Have you ever had milk toast—or made a variation on it? Tell us about it in the comments.

Listen Now

On our new weekly podcast, two friends separated by the Atlantic take questions and compare notes on everything from charcuterie trends to scone etiquette.

Listen Now

See what other Food52 readers are saying.

  • David Dashiell
    David Dashiell
  • Solveig Warren
    Solveig Warren
  • Sarah Cornell
    Sarah Cornell
  • Martha Shaffer
    Martha Shaffer
  • Bonnie Hillman Riley
    Bonnie Hillman Riley
Sarah E Daniels

Written by: Sarah E Daniels

It's mostly a matter of yeast.


David D. September 8, 2016
The great cartoonist H T Webster had a character called Caspar Milquetoast, the Timid Soul in the 1920s. It became a popular epithet for timid, ineffectual male.
Solveig W. May 15, 2016
On shrove Tuesday In Scandinavia we eat a sweet bun topped with sugar crystals and a slice of Marcipan in the middle boiled milk poured over and after bun is soaked and sloppy with drenched milk eat it with gusto! Delicious and warming on a winter's day.
Sarah C. May 15, 2016
Thanks to this article, I went out on a limb and put cubes of cinnamon toast on a bowl of still-warm arborio rice pudding. That's OK for breakfast, right?!
Sarah E. May 15, 2016
Absolutely acceptable breakfast food
Martha S. May 12, 2016
My mother always made it by making good buttery cinnamon toast first broiled to get it really melted), then breaking that up into the milk....heaven!
Bonnie H. May 11, 2016
Maybe it's something Pennsylvania Dutch, which I am. I grew up being given Cracker Soup when I didn't feel quite up to par - warm milk, crumbled up saltine crackers, and a bit of butter. It was delicious!
VeganWithaYoYo May 11, 2016
Sounds easy and tasty. Might try it in the near future with soy milk.

But much more importantly, I'm somewhat disappointed that no one has made a clever comment using the word milquetoast yet.
sarah May 10, 2016
when I was still in kindergarten (around 1999) my parents would make me Zwieback mit Milch (rusk with milk). It was reserved for the sick and sad, and demonstrated it's healing powers on many occasions