Olive Oil

The Groves (& The Family) Behind our Italian Olive Oil CSA

April  4, 2016

If, as a kid, you (or your middle school class) ever adopted a polar bear or a panda bear or a star or a river, you know the flurry of warm-fuzzies that follow: the ones you get from pitching in towards a collective cause, and the instinctive, immediate empathy involved in getting to call a sliver of it your own.

For a grown-up version of this, you can now adopt a hundreds-years-old Puglian olive tree.

Especially Puglia, a company that promotes the oils and craft of a handful of Italian olive growers and oil producers, caught our attention because of their tree adoption program. By adopting one of the olive trees on one of the four farms Especially Puglia works with—which you can do by way of our Shopyou'll get a wooden gift box containing a pretty ceramic cruet, a 3-liter can of extra-virgin, single-origin olive oil, a tiny funnel, and an adoption certificate.

Olive groves in Puglia. Photo by Balazs Glodi

Talking to Michele Iadarola, Especially Puglia's founder, I realized that I haven't given a lot of thought to my olive oil the way I have to the rest of what I eat—my coffee, my milk, my bread, my eggs. And this is what Michele expected: Americans tend to buy their olive oil from grocery stores, and their thoughts (like mine) turn largely to price first and everything else afterward.

Michele, who grew up on an olive farm in Puglia (one of the four farms from which Especially Puglia sources), wanted to connect American buyers with the same system that many Italians take part in: You buy into a farm's olive-growing and oil-production processes before the harvest, CSA-style, with an early investment in the land and the plants and the farmers, and an understanding that the payoff will come after the harvest. But most Americans can't go to a farmers market (and certainly not an Italian farmers market) for their weekly fix of olive oil, the way we do for other staples, and Michele wanted to fill that void.

Photo by Balazs Glodi

When you adopt an olive tree, "you get excited about the new crop [of olives] on a specific piece of land," Michele explained to me over the phone. "It's your olive tree that makes oil for you every year. If I were at the olive grove myself, I'd go to the farmer and say, 'I want this much olive oil,' and stock up for one year. Getting this box is sort of like passing that tradition to our general customers."

Shop the Story

So you adopt an olive tree. Three liters of olive oil is a lot to ask from one particular tree, but your tree puts in its contribution; the 3 liters of olive oil you receive upon adoption is the collective effort of all of the trees on Masseria Carpine, Michele's family's grove. Extend the adoption by "subscribing" (this is the CSA-style bit), and get a year's worth of olive oil: Three more 3-liter cans will arrive over the course of the coming year, one from each of the different groves—Masseria Carpine, Masseria San Giusto, Castel Fiorentino, and Carolina Villani Estate—Especially Puglia works with.

Michele and his father in their grove in Puglia. Photo by Balazs Glodi

The effect, flavorwise, of buying single-origin oil is obvious, the reasoning the same as why we buy wines from single-varietal grapes and vineyards we know we like: You can really taste not only the specific variety of olives (there are four between the four farms: Peranzana, Coratina, Santa Caterina, and Leccino), but also the land-based nuances between the farms, even though they are all in northern Puglia at the heel of Italy's boot. "Each olive oil and grove has its own tasting profile based on the soil, the time [the olives] are harvested, the variety of olive," Michele said.

There's also the added benefit of knowing who grew your olives—in Especially Puglia's case, mostly families, including Michele's. His parents and siblings continue to run Masseria Carpine, an olive grove that's been in his family for three generations; his great-grandfather planted the trees. And you can go to Puglia and meet them (Michele's family and trees, and the families and trees of the three other groves) through the farm-stay program Michele has developed, and lend a hand during the harvest season from September through November.

Sheep moseying through, munching on fallen olives. Photo by Balazs Glodi

Michele wants his consumers to know how the whole process works: how the olive trees in many of these groves are 200 to 300 years old ("like monuments," he said), that the olives are cold-pressed in Puglia within 8 hours of the time they're harvested, and that it's truly "extra virgin" oil—that's the first oil that comes out of the press (not all olive oil marketed as extra virgin actually is).

The other thing he wants consumers to know: Olive oil tastes differently when it's fresh versus when it's been sitting out for a couple of months (or longer). It tastes stronger and greener, "more peppery, with a kick in your throat because it's so fresh," he told me.

So what to do with them? Here's how Michele recommends using each of the oils they send in the subscription service:

Photo by Mark Weinberg

Masseria Carpine

Michele's family's grove
This is Michele's favorite of the four oils (though he may be biased, as it's from his family's grove); it's made of Santa Caterina and Coratina olives that are harvested and processed together. "Very green color, big aroma, a bit peppery and a bit sweet, and balanced beautifully," says Michele, making it a very good all-purpose oil. Use in salads, soups, and pastas.

(You'll get this oil whether you adopt a tree and leave it at that or you subscribe for the year; oil from the other three groves is only included in the year subscription.)

Masseria San Giusto

The grove of the family that processes the olives
Made of Coratina olives, this oil is "very strong, a little bitter, very grassy," says Michele, and good on everything but fish, which needs something a little more delicate. It's good for roasting since its flavor holds up.

Castel Fiorentino

A grove belonging to a relative of the San Giusto owners
Since this oil is made from "very sweet olives"—Peranzana and Leccino—"very balanced, and a bit fruity," it is good for fish (and vegetables). Drizzle on bread or over fish or vegetables.

Carolina Villani Estate

The grove of one of Michele's maternal cousins
This oil is similar to the Fiorentino oil, but made exclusively with Peranzana olives ("one of the perfect olives," says Michele), and thus even fruitier and very rounded in flavor. Drizzle over soft cheeses or bean salads.

Already scheming about how to use them? (Or dreaming of a Puglian farm-stay already? Same.) Head over to our Shop.

Listen Now

On Black & Highly Flavored, co-hosts Derek Kirk and Tamara Celeste shine a light on the need-to-know movers and shakers of our food & beverage industry.

Listen Now

See what other Food52 readers are saying.

  • kofaw74547
  • D.L.
  • foodie100
  • HC
  • Michele Iadarola
    Michele Iadarola
Writing and cooking in Brooklyn.


kofaw74547 May 27, 2020
I have found a new project like this in Greece. The olive oil quality is pretty amazing! I have adopted a tree as a wedding gift for my best friends marriage.
It is called Mia Elia and their website is https://www.miaelia.com/
kofaw74547 May 27, 2020
I have found a new project like this in Greece. The olive oil quality is pretty amazing! I have adopted a tree as a wedding gift for my best friends marriage.
It is called Mia Elia and their website is https://www.miaelia.com/
D.L. April 6, 2016
Great job Michele! Very nice packaging! It's always refreshing to see young people going back to their roots! I also like the price point: 12 liters of super fresh and authentic extra virgin olive oil and the gorgeous ceramic cruet for $370 is a pretty good deal.
foodie100 April 5, 2016
Im pretty sure this concept has been done before? https://food52.com/blog/4036-pressing-olives-with-jason-gibb-of-nudo-olive-oil
HC April 4, 2016
This is a great idea! If you can source this back to the four farmers and and how they mill/process their oils (you must have the most modern/ ultra clean milling equipment and you need a master miller running the equipment- the old donkey and stone wheel method, although romantic will ALWAYS create defects in the oil !) this can be exceptional oil. I love that you tell the varieties of the olives (there are over 2000 different olives in the world) and what makes Italy so exceptional is they have more than 400 varieties in their small country which makes for some exceptional oils. Do not think that ALL Extra Virgin Olive oil in Italy is fake or touched by Mafia hands - the 60 minute report should not make you feel that all Italian oil is fake because this SIMPLY IS NOT TRUE. Italy has some extremely passionate, dedicated growers that create ultra premium oils that are beautiful! What makes Italy unique in the world is the fact that no other country has as many cultivars (over 400) which allows such a variety and diversity of product. The oils you should be most afraid of are the ones you can buy in your grocery store for $2.99 a litre -those are most surely NOT EVOO!! I have been taking professional Olive oil tasting courses in Italy for years so I know a little bit about this magnificent/misunderstood product.. When buying any EVOO I think the most important things to look for are A HARVEST DATE - not the same as a BEST Before date (if an oil is harvested in Oct 2015 - it is at its best for up to 2 years if stored properly ) - Good oil should have a level of bitterness and pungency (does it make you cough!) these are positive attributes - taste the oil- take a tablespoon and swirl it in your mouth, smile, then suck in some air 2 or 3 times and swallow it. Does it taste peppery at the back of your tongue, does it make you cough! GOOD then its probably a good, fresh oil, lovingly crafted. Whether you get oils from wonderful producers in California (there are many!!) or Spain or Italy, I encourage you not to save it for a "special " occasion - this is actually fresh fruit juice the better the fresher, don't save it or you will miss it when it has its best MOJO!! Use it lavishly on everything - its not just for Caprese Salad!!
Michele I. April 4, 2016
Ciao! Michele here from Especially Puglia! I am not surprised that as a Food52 reader you have been paying attention to the press around olive oil - and like me that you care deeply about knowing where your food comes from. It's true that a lot of Italian olive oil sold in grocery stores in America is not EVOO. I started Especially Puglia to combat this problem. Many of the small farmers in Puglia, including my family who owns olive groves, produce olive oil for their personal use and sell to their friends and family. They would sell the remainder of the olive oil to large corporations, and this oil, once out of their hands, would eventually become blended with other oils. Our family's olive farms produce small batch single harvest EVOO for sale through Especially Puglia. It's our mission to cut out the middle man, and the question mark that comes with it, and bring extra virgin olive oil straight from the farms to you.

We are even inviting anyone interested in learning more about small batch production to visit the farms in Puglia during the olive oil harvest in the fall, see it in action, and get to know the farmers!
Derek M. November 10, 2020
I'm just starting to read and see your site and will be ordering something for Christmas gifts for family.With my name being Giusto to see these bottles in our kitchen will be sweet.Loving I've oil as I do is just as sweet.
Kelly K. April 4, 2016
As great of a concept as it sounds, I would not trust any EVOO coming from Italy...sorry.
Jon M. April 4, 2016
Italy is notorious for selling EVO that isn't EVO. Does Food 52 guarantee that it is what they claim?
PaulaE April 4, 2016
That's what I'm asking below. Did you see this? http://www.cbsnews.com/news/60-minutes-agromafia-food-fraud/ If this Food 52 partnership with an honest, non-Mafia-connected farmer is real, I'm in.
Alyssa April 4, 2016
This concept is absurdly cool.
PaulaE April 4, 2016
Can we be sure this olive oil CSA program is free of the influence of Italian organized crime? I would love to support olive farmers who have thrown off the yoke of that terrible, corrupt system.
Caroline L. April 4, 2016
hi there paula, we definitely appreciate this concern—and hear you. having spoken to michele myself, i can tell you that he feels very passionately about producing olive oil that both honors the families that make it (his family and a handful of family friends) and the olives themselves, and about doing it transparently. i don't want to speak for michele, but i'm sure he'd be happy to answer any questions you have! you can find the company's contact info here: http://especiallypuglia.com