If You Only Bake One More Summer Dessert, Let It Be This

September 20, 2017

Marian Burros plum torte this. Marian Burros plum torte that.

The recipe is cherished and foolproof and time-tested. It's so beloved and requested that, as Kristen Miglore pointed out in Genius Recipes—which of course included the dessert—when the New York Times published the recipe for the sixth year in a row, they gave it the headline, "Once More (Sigh), the Plum Torte."

Hey, we know you. Photo by James Ransom

I myself had baked so many of these cakes this summer that, while I was by no means torte-tired, my eyes began to wander. I started scouring the internet for something different to do with the ten to twelve prune plums I'm obligated to buy every time I spot them.

Marian's crumble isn't world-renowned the way its cakey cousin is. But that doesn't mean it's not deserving of fame and fortune.
Luisa Weiss

It was my infidelity that led me to the other Boleyn girl Marian Burros plum dessert: plum crumble, the glory of which has been professed by Luisa Weiss on The Wednesday Chef and Molly Wizenberg on Orangette, too.

The crumble may not be as ubiquitous as the cake, but I implore you (I implore you): Make this for summer dessert finale, while plums are still a common sight and before you mosey on to apples and pumpkins.

A perfect compromise, I would say, between crumble, spice cake, and cookie.
Molly Wizenberg

Burros' crumble is shallow and top-heavy: a jammy layer of tart plums blanketed by a lumpy crust that my boyfriend aptly compared to a giant snickerdoodle cookie, warm with cinnamon. It's as easy-going as the torte, too The plums are simply halved, pitted, and tossed with spices and a little flour and sugar. The dough is streusel-like (flour, sugar, baking powder, salt, and a beaten egg), just pinched apart and scattered over the fruit.

Are you a plum... or are you prune? I'm confused. Photo by James Ransom

Its glorious cookie-cake texture comes from the final step: Before the pan goes into the oven, you'll pour melted butter all over the top. The butter binds clumps of dough together, so that they form a craggy crust that's got fluff and crisp, lightness and density. Gosh, if I had to choose between Burros' crumble—fruity and spicy, squishy and crispy—and her cake... I just might choose the crumble.

Shop the Story

Let it be your summer's last dessert hoorah. With a pan on the table, a pint of vanilla ice cream, and six spoons standing ready (though, you could easily polish it off among four!), you won't feel like you missed out on a thing.

What's the last summer dessert you'll make before you head into apple and squash territory? Tell us in the comments below!

The Magical Mini Guide to Cozy Weekends
View Guide
The Magical Mini Guide to Cozy Weekends

Whether you're in the mood for some soup-simmering, leaf-peeping, or nothing at all, your dream weekend awaits...

View Guide

See what other Food52 readers are saying.

I used to work at Food52. I'm probably the person who picked all of the cookie dough out of the cookie dough ice cream.

1 Comment

Lisa S. January 5, 2019
I have made Marion's torte so many times, sometimes with other fruit, but always during plum season several times.. my neighbors have a tree or two and there are bushels of plums at the end of every summer... I soaked some in rum and let them sit, forgot them at Christmas.. I may just have to try this with the drunken plums...