All About Canned Fish

January  7, 2014

Inspired by conversations on the Food52 Hotline, we're sharing tips and tricks that make navigating all of our kitchens easier and more fun.

Today: How to choose and use your pantry's saviors.

Canned fish from Food52

Everything I learned about canned fish I learned in kindergarten. Mainly, tuna sandwiches get soggy. Fast. 

But today, with many eco- and health-friendly options, the biggest problem is no longer two floppy pieces of bread, but deciding which brands to buy. And that’s why we’re going to break this canned fish situation down.

Before we dive into the specifics, let’s go over some basics.

The Key to the Can 

Canned fish from Food52

To determine sustainability, look at catch method, catch location, and species. These details will help decipher if a product was fished responsibly, and enable cross-checking with resources like the Marine Stewardship Council, Fishwise, and Seafood Watch (if you so wish).

As for catch method, choose products labeled as troll, pole and line, hook and line, FAD-free, or school caught. These terms refer to selective fishing measures that limit disruption to the environment and bycatch (or inclusion of non-targeted fish like dolphins, turtles, Ariel...). 

For health benefits, keep things natural. Fish packed in water, olive oil, or flavored sauces means fish that has been cooked twice (i.e. drier meat and lost Omega-3s). To retain superfood super powers, choose salmon and tuna cooked in their own juices, once. And look for labels that read “fresh-caught” or “never frozen.” Rough translation: rich flavor, no need for mayo.

Overall, just avoid ambiguity. If you have a choice between tuna or a can of wild-caught Albacore from the Pacific Northwest, go with number two. The more information the better. Because let’s be real -- would you rather accept a blind date with “a man” or a man named Michael from Virginia with a degree in neuroscience? I think I’ve made my point here.


Tuna from Food52

How to choose it 

Both wild-caught skipjack (alias: light tuna) and albacore (alias: white tuna) from the Pacific Northwest and British Columbia are sustainable choices. But here’s the catch: larger albacore tends to contain more mercury than smaller skipjack. So when buying albacore, pick brands like Raincoast, Wild Planet, and American Tuna, which specifically target smaller and naturally lower-mercury fish.

How to use it

See 6 inspired dinners here,


Salmon from Food52

How to choose it

Any species of wild-caught salmon from Alaska is a sustainable choice due to the awesome regulations in these parts (go Alaska!). Just avoid anything farmed or from the Atlantic. 

How to use it

For a quick fix, try spicy salmon tacos, miso-flavored salmon fried rice, salmon cakes, or Salmon Kedgeree.


Sardines from Food52

How to choose it

Because they reproduce quickly, sardines rule as the poster child for sustainable seafood. But catch location remains important; choose Pacific sardines over those from the Atlantic and overseas to avoid overfishing. 

How to use it

Because most products come packed in flavored oils and marinara sauces, sometimes all you need is a cracker or a fork. A toasted baguette with a dollop of mustard doesn’t hurt. And of course, there’s always butter


Anchovies from Food52

How to choose it

Most edible anchovies hail from Europe, with only one Argentinian fishery currently receiving MSC certification. So finding sustainable anchovies gets, well, a little fishy. For an eco-guarantee, look for the MSC seal; use “product finders” like the one on; rely on your earth-friendly grocer; or use Pacific sardines instead.

How to use it

Skip the salt, add the anchovies. Use this tutorial for pastas, pizzas, dressings, and meals even kids will enjoy.

Oysters & Clams

How to choose it

Because they are typically cultured and farmed, oysters and clams fall into the highly sustainable category. 

How to use it

Make dinner for breakfast and mix oysters and clams into a Sunday morning hash. Or this bloody mary. Or both.

What are your favorite ways to use canned fish? Let us know in the comments!

Order now

A New Way to Dinner, co-authored by Food52's founders Amanda Hesser and Merrill Stubbs, is an indispensable playbook for stress-free meal-planning (hint: cook foundational dishes on the weekend and mix and match ‘em through the week).

Order now


Sandy M. January 9, 2014
What a great story. My Mom was put on dialysis at age 85, had<br />to be on a very restricted diet, and the dialysis was not a very<br />pleasant situation. I was amazed at the dialysis center,<br />so many young patients. Be very thankful for good health! Sandy
Bevi January 7, 2014
Perhaps one of the biggest culinary revelations I have had in recent years was making and enjoying First Night in Florence spaghetti, prepared with good tuna packed in oil.<br />