I added 2 Tablespoons of cornstarch to apple pie filling instead of 2 teaspoons. I feel like a moron. Can I salvage this or should I go to the store for more apples? Thanks.
Are you channeling your best self with this comment? (If you're not sure, check out our Code of Conduct.)
Monita is a Recipe Tester for Food52
If you have the time, I'd start from scratch only because CS can make your filling really gummy
Thanks! That was my inclination, but I always want to make sure there are no secret tricks that I'm unaware of.
Pegeen is a trusted home cook.
Without knowing more about your pie... assuming it doesn't have a top crust, or that you haven't put on a top crust yet. And assuming the problem is that the apples don't seem juicy enough or have a cornstarch taste. You could put the apples in a saucepan, as they are, with a few tablespoons of apple juice (or even grape or cranberry), or a few tablespoons of a sweet fruit jam. Saute them on very low heat (or the jam will burn) and the apples will start to release some juice and the cornstarch should get diluted. Plan B: Just pile a lot of ice cream on top. (And you're not a moron - everyone has Thanksgiving trials and tribulations! Good luck!)
Ice cream is always the solution to any problem at our house! I forgot to mention it was a cooked filling. Glad I started over. It seems that I can bake pretty much everything except pie- I should have brought croissants instead! Thanks for your help.
Nancy is a trusted home cook.
following Pegeen - when in doubt, do a little tinkering and rename the dish. If you rinse and/or saute your filling, add some lemon juice or a few more fruits, you have fruit compote - with our without ice cream. and if it doesn't work, get more apples to make another pie.
You can probably rinse it off, just make sure you use cold water for it. The apples might lose a touch of sweetness and flavour, but that can be added back with an extra pinch of sugar and some lemon juice.
You'll put this recipe on repeat.
Extra Chewy Sugar Cookies
Wallet-Friendly Ways to Eat Eggs
Spread the Word
The New Jersey Boardwalk of My Childhood
Hot Dog Spaghetti: A Love Story