The Piglet2014 / First Round, 2014

The New Persian Kitchen  vs. Family Table

The New Persian Kitchen

Louisa Shafia

Get the Book

Family Table

Michael Romano and Karen Stabiner

Get the Book

The Judgment

F849be70-2a55-41a2-ba9d-44d375609530--brian_boitano

By Brian Boitano

I’m no stranger to competition, but when two packages arrive, each containing cookbooks that are to be pitted against each other, even I take a moment to process. Normally I add cookbooks to my collection or I don't. This time, I'm to thoroughly read both, cook a meal from each, and choose a winner. 

I turn to package one: Family Table.

Conceptually this is great book. It’s all about extended family meals; it’s not overly fancy or complicated, but rather it’s full of what chefs make for each other -- and for their staff, or “families” -- when they eat together. It gives a behind-the-scenes glance at what it’s like to run a restaurant, and of what goes on in the kitchen. 

The look of the book is moody, with candid photos in black and white and food photos taken with dark, stark backgrounds. Chefs grace the front cover -- a first impression that might prove intimidating to some novice cooks. 

But it’s not, really: The recipes are primarily filled with ingredients that are probably already in your average home cook’s lexicon (or perhaps pantry), and they have fairly simple preparations. When recipes do require a slightly longer time commitment, most often that means hands-off cooking time. And for those items not already in my pantry, there’s an in-depth section to turn to, full of information on unusual beans and grains. It's a compelling look at ingredients a lot of cookbooks seem to gloss over. 

The table of contents gave me pause, though. Flip a few pages into the book, and you get only categories rather than the dishes themselves. As someone who likes to get a sense of the scope of the book before I dive in, I would have appreciated not having to browse an entire section to find a particular recipe.

I browsed on, and made the Braised Red Cabbage with Roasted Pears, which required a long stove-top simmer of cabbage and onions with apple juice and white wine. But while the photo in the book looked perfectly slouchy, slack in all the right places, my cabbage retained a bit of crunch, even after I simmered it for an hour as the recipe directed. Simmered longer, it began to relax, and became the dish I hoped it would be. The next day it was even better. It’d be perfect made ahead of time for a dinner party, I thought, along with the next recipe I tested: Cola-Braised Short Ribs. 

They required 2 1/2 hours to cook, but I didn’t mind the time investment. (Something you might not know about me: I’m a bit of a braiseaholic.) After their long stint in the oven, the short ribs were good -- tender and savory, just as they should be. But again I couldn’t get my dish to look much like the picture in the book, and this time it was the braising liquid’s fault. In the photo it was thick and syrupy; in my bowl it was thin and a little anemic, even after I tried reducing it for longer than the recipe suggested. I wondered, after having problems with my first two recipes, how many times they were tested.

Family Table’s Roasted Cauliflower with Lemon-Caper Dressing changed my mind. It was simple and came together quickly, and the dressing -- made of lemon juice, capers, egg yolk, and vegetable oil -- was the perfect, tart foil for the cauliflower. This dish will be a go-to side for me from now on.

Package two is up next, and I open it knowing that my last impression of Family Table would be hard to beat. 

On first glance, the best way to describe The New Persian Kitchen by Louisa Shafia is fun. Visually, it’s very pleasing; as I flipped through, I found myself loving the layout, the bright colors, the photos. Each made the recipes -- filled with different flavors and textures -- that much more appealing. I felt compelled to try something new.

But before I could, I had to track down some of the unusual ingredients the book calls for, which proved to be difficult. Even after a trip to a specialty store, some of the Persian ingredients were too hard to find. But hunting for new and interesting ingredients is not without its merits or rewards, and if it’s something you enjoy, then this is a book for you. 

Once I gathered my ingredients, I made Parvin’s Tamarind Stuffed Fish. Its recipe was easy to follow, and when it came out of the oven, it was absolutely beautiful -- something I could picture being a centerpiece dish at a party. The barberries, ground almonds, tamarind, and fresh minced herbs made the dish wonderfully fragrant and colorful. I made a note to remind myself to cook this again. 

As you go through the book, you get much more than the recipes. Peppered throughout is a lot of interesting information -- from three different methods for juicing pomegranates to the difference between Persian and Iranian restaurants. Pass a few more recipes and you’ll find tips for preparing whole grains, then a guide to Persian ingredients. Pass more still, and you’ll learn how make some of her dishes vegetarian-friendly.

Louisa’s Roasted Stuffed Artichokes with Mint Oil were next. I dutifully stuffed each artichoke with ricotta, saffron, and lemon zest, and drizzled them all with lemon juice and mint oil before roasting. The recipe was clear, the preparation simple, and the resulting dish -- just like the last -- tasted complex, fragrant, and like it had taken much more work to make than it actually had.

In the introduction, Louisa explains that her aim is to blend the foreign and the familiar, with a focus on fresh food and healthful cooking. That is exactly what she does, and it makes the book one of the most refreshing I’ve cooked from in a while.

The New Persian Kitchen emphasizes whole grains and new flours and uses spice over fat, and does it all without being overly virtuous. Her food is new, it’s fun, and though I’m glad to have both of these books in my library, I’ll turn to Louisa more often for her fresh perspective. I know she’ll be the one to, more reliably, stretch the boundaries of my taste buds. 

For me, The New Persian Kitchen takes this round. 

And the winner is…

The New Persian Kitchen

The New Persian Kitchen

Get the Book

Do you Agree? (57 comments)

23b88974-7a89-4ef5-a567-d442bb75da04--avatar
23b88974-7a89-4ef5-a567-d442bb75da04--avatar
4be0eac3-6b63-477d-8b32-16320a982ef2--face-1

over 1 year ago Naomi Manygoats

Well written review and have to say I quite agree with it!

23b88974-7a89-4ef5-a567-d442bb75da04--avatar

over 1 year ago erinsk

Can't wait to try Luisa's newest book, it sounds wonderful!

23b88974-7a89-4ef5-a567-d442bb75da04--avatar

over 1 year ago Dr ROK

Living in Nebraska, I doubt I'LL be able to get many of the ingredients needed for recipes in this book. For me Family Table sounds like a better fit.

0bc38656-14c6-4cbd-bd5e-4691bad4cedb--20140102_134940

over 1 year ago Joanne

I've cooked Iranian food before and it has to be hands down one of my favourite cuisines. I already have one Persian cookbook that I truly enjoy (Pomegranates and Roses) but would not hesitate to add 'The New Persian Kitchen' to my cookbook collection.

23b88974-7a89-4ef5-a567-d442bb75da04--avatar

over 1 year ago sandriavdh

Thank you for the detailed review. My mouth was watering by the end! Thinking I may need to add yet another cook book to my ever growing collection.

8f5038ed-8aca-4d33-aef7-8a0ce63adc40--img00019-20100929-0432_1_

over 1 year ago sexyLAMBCHOPx

sexyLAMBCHOPx is a trusted home cook.

Family Table seems typical and familiar, so reading through The New Persian Kitchen would be interesting cooking adventure for me.

7a609a50-8972-46ea-a6cd-e9c209e3d690--img_8592

over 1 year ago tyrannyofcake

I've coveted The New Persian Cookbook since I ran across it in a kitchen shop on vacation!

23b88974-7a89-4ef5-a567-d442bb75da04--avatar

over 1 year ago XenaB

Thank you for an excellent review - thoughtful, well written and fair. I have The New Persian Kitchen and love it. The recipes work, the photos are beautiful and the layout is clean. I also loved the personal stories and learning about Persian culture.

23b88974-7a89-4ef5-a567-d442bb75da04--avatar

over 1 year ago beejay45

Family Table has been on my to-buy list since it came out. Why I haven't bought it is a mystery. but it's still on the list after this review.

The New Persian Kitchen, too, is on my wishlist. I had a lot of friends from Iran during the time I was at Uni and ate a lot of amazing foods. Haven't thought about that in years, but now I can revisit those meals. Excellent review because I actually am interested in the layout and photographs as well as the recipes. Covered it all! ;)

23b88974-7a89-4ef5-a567-d442bb75da04--avatar

over 1 year ago Elveenah

The New Persian Kitchen sounds FABULOUS. I think I may have to have it.

23b88974-7a89-4ef5-a567-d442bb75da04--avatar

over 1 year ago Juliebell

I am so impressed with the reviews this year. Each one has been very deliberate, educational and very even handed. Best Piglet yet!

23b88974-7a89-4ef5-a567-d442bb75da04--avatar

over 1 year ago LittleFrier

Now this is a great review. Well done.

B3ccde4b-59da-4008-923d-de7c01022b4b--944210_10100465232422491_669231675_n

over 1 year ago Amanda Marie

Although I often fall slave to recipes that are quick and easy, there are few things more rewarding as a home cook than getting inspired by and creating something beautiful with exotic ingredients that introduce new and unique flavor profiles. I love that Brian embraced both the challenge and excitement of this and shared that with us in his review!

23b88974-7a89-4ef5-a567-d442bb75da04--avatar

over 1 year ago jess m

The artichoke recipe sounds wonderful, can't wait to try it!

23b88974-7a89-4ef5-a567-d442bb75da04--avatar

over 1 year ago Allison (Spontaneous Tomato)

I'm excited about both of these cookbooks, now! (Especially the Persian Kitchen one...)

09e96f32-5fc6-465f-ae05-9f156b104560--family_feb2012_version_2

over 1 year ago garlic&lemon

Oops! I was a careless reader. The artichoke recipe is calling my name! (Well, the other one is, too.) Hmm, something has to go to make way for the new.

09e96f32-5fc6-465f-ae05-9f156b104560--family_feb2012_version_2

over 1 year ago garlic&lemon

Mr. Boitano has set the bar for great reviews this year. He was thorough, respectful, & candid. Although I have no room for more cookbooks, I might have to spring for Persian Kitchen. The cauliflower recipe is calling my name!

8bbce907-3b5e-4c8c-be5c-c64e6c780d63--birthday_2012

over 1 year ago luvcookbooks

Meg is a trusted home cook.

Want both. This is the best Piglet ever.

37c46e71-9105-4c1a-99b5-ca8c8f9fa3ac--photo_4-

over 1 year ago twinjadojo

Absolutely getting Ms. Shafia's book. So glad to hear that her modern take on ancient flavours yields solid, and not just trendy, results.

23b88974-7a89-4ef5-a567-d442bb75da04--avatar

over 1 year ago Megan

The New Persian Kitchen has such a colorful cover