The Piglet2016 / First Round, 2016

Zahav vs. The Food Lab


Michael Solomonov

Get the Book

The Food Lab

J. Kenji López-Alt

Get the Book

Judged by: Phyllis Grant

Phyllis Grant spent her twenties in New York City dancing at Juilliard and cooking at Bouley and Nobu, and her thirties having children, teaching yoga, and guiding women through childbirth. These days, she can be found in Berkeley, writing, developing recipes, and photographing, or online at Food52, Sunset Magazine, Oprah, Saveur, Food & Wine, and Real Simple. Her writing has been featured in several anthologies including Best Food Writing 2015. She is getting oh so close to releasing her first cookbook out into the world.

The Judgment

To J. Kenji López-Alt and Michael Solomonov:

I love cookbooks. I have stacks of them in my kitchen, my hallway, next to my bed. They are towering columns of comfort. They bring color and light to each room. I flip through them for inspiration. I’m writing one. But unless I’m making pastries, I don’t follow recipes. And my kids don’t either: For thirteen years, I have been teaching them the importance of playing in the kitchen. Tweaking, adjusting, rejiggering. Listening to their guts. 

Then The Piglet came along. 

My daughter thought it was unfair to compare your books. They’re too different, mom. It’s just not right. 

I couldn’t agree more. Cerebral, meticulous, scientific treatise on sous vide cooking and burgers and sticky buns versus Israeli food? 

And then I went into a tailspin trying to define what makes a good cookbook. 

My kids weren’t very helpful. That’s easy, said my son, a good cookbook has photos that make you want to lick the pages. He puts Aleppo pepper on everything and eats pickles for breakfast while my daughter is all about mug cakes and freakshakes. So, of course, from my daughter: Mom, a good cookbook has a nice balance of everything. Especially desserts. 

Unlike novels and memoirs, cookbooks are often judged by their looks. Here’s what I might have said about these two at first glance: 

The Food Lab has a serene and inviting cover. Almost 1000 pages. Your head will spin. You will need a martini. Or a sherpa. So. Many. Words. So much exciting science to dive into. So many awkwardly composed and poorly-lit photos screaming out for some natural light. 

Zahav is 373 pages of Israeli home cooking inspired by Michael Solomonov’s Philadelphia restaurant of the same name. It is filled with stories of tragedy and triumph and reconnecting with his Israeli heritage. It’s uncomfortably styled. Overly lit. Looks a bit nineties. 

But how could I possibly know if your books were good unless I cooked from them? Would I forgive some of these foibles? Or would they become more glaring?

We put colorful Post-its next to every single recipe we wanted to make. 

I was very strict. 

I didn’t let my son put Sriracha in your Caesar dressing, López-Alt. And Solomonov, no Nutella in your babka, even though we wanted to. 

No improvisation allowed.

I am proud to say that my kids and I managed to cook over 20 recipes from each of your books. 

Before I continue, I would like to lodge a formal complaint against you, J. Kenji López-Alt, for the overuse of the following words: AWESOME, ULTIMATE, BEST, PERFECT, FOOLPROOF, EASY. 

But here is why I forgive you:

You taught me how to spatchcock a chicken.

You explained why my scrambled eggs weep. I now add salt to the eggs 15 minutes before I cook them.  

You got me to throw three generations of egg-poaching technique out the window. We no longer add salt and vinegar to the boiling water and create a whirlpool with a butter knife. We now strain the loose whites away and slide the egg into the boiling water. No stray tentacles of whites. No murky acidic water. Just a tight white exterior hugging a just-firmed yolk. 

You introduced us to light and fluffy buttermilk pancakes, immersion blender mayonnaise, Peruvian-style jalapeño sauce, steak with red wine pan sauce (that my son is still talking about), 3-ingredient blue cheese dressing, cheesy Hasselback potato gratin, sticky buns (six batches, bitches).

Just yesterday, I was slicing cheese and buttering bread and my son said, Stop, I hope you’re doing that the Food Lab way. Because, thanks to you, regular old grilled cheese just won’t do. They now want melted cheddar inside and crunchy Parmesan outside.

Thank you for explaining everything to me. Wait. Except for one thing: Why did the sickly sweet orange cream cheese glaze for your sticky buns keep splitting?

Solomonov: Your first chapter in Zahav, “Tehina: The Secret Sauce,” should win a James Beard award. I got so caught up in your magic that I overnighted two jars of Soom, your favorite tehina, from Amazon. I wanted to make amba tehina, harissa tehina, black garlic tehina. 

And, dude, I will never buy hummus again. I will always do as you do. I will pulverize a head of garlic with lemon juice, pass it through a fine strainer, and slowly whisk in tehina, water, salt, and cumin until it resembles a shiny pourable icing and tastes like a savory, nutty mousse. I will store this gloriousness in my fridge and mix it with puréed chickpeas for hummus, eggplant for babaganoush. I will use it as a salad dressing base. I will place it on top, under, around, and in between meat and vegetables.

My friend Margi offered to help me test recipes. She took one look at The Food Lab and said: I don’t even know what I would do with this. But Zahav inspired her to host a Middle Eastern feast. Her main dish was your pargiyot (baby chicken) three ways with harissa, amba, and onion marinades. She and I agreed that on the page, they all looked and sounded quite different, but once grilled—while delicious—they all looked a similar greenish-orange and tasted virtually the same. 

I made your chocolate babka. Such a solid recipe all the way through to the end. And so fun for the kids. But I think it needs more salt. Maybe some brown butter?

We need to talk about the fried eggplant with tehina and pomegranate seeds: The recipe said to cook the ¾-inch rounds in ½-inch of shimmering oil, five minutes per side. I’ve never experienced slices of eggplant cooking in ten minutes and, sadly, by the time they were creamy and soft inside, they tasted like oily hockey pucks. They went out with the compost.

But thank you for your beautiful tehina cookies. I kept several batches in my freezer and ate them all while binge-watching the second season of Transparent. Did you know they’re even better with vanilla, a bit of salt, and rolled in sugar? And it helps to slightly undercook them. And you should try them with hazelnut butter. See? I tweak. 

I make a lamb pie with about 20 ingredients in the filling, so I was psyched for the simplicity of your beef pie. I loved adding that field of sesame seeds to the top that sinks down into the buttery pastry. But it was missing excitement (maybe 15 ingredients?). 

Until a month ago, if you’d looked in the back of my fridge, you would have found a jar of your pickled persimmons and dates with dried limes. Texture: mealy. Flavor: medicinal. I couldn’t even give them away.

I really thought your book would win. Zahav is more my kind of food: Hella flavor. Nothing precious. My biggest criticism is that there is too much emphasis on your personal journey and not enough attention given to the recipes. People have raved to me about your restaurant. What got lost in translation? What didn’t get onto the page? Why do too many of your dishes fall flat? 

There are some shots of you eating at home with your family. These are the meals that intrigue me. These are the stories I want to hear. The foods I want to taste. I want to sit at that table; I wish more of the book felt this way. But I’m not giving your cookbook away. This month, I’m going to make your shakshouka, Turkish coffee ice cream, twice-cooked eggplant, fluke crudo, coffee-braised brisket, lachuch, and borekas.

López-Alt, your book is as intimidating as shit. It is oddly structured and filled with so many details that often it’s hard to find the gems. But part of the joy I got from this book was discovering something new every time I flipped it open; and it was only because of the Piglet that I forced myself to excavate. I would like to thank you from the bottom of my heart for testing the fuck out of these recipes. I have never seen anything like it. 

And the winner is…

The Food Lab: Better Home Cooking Through Science

The Food Lab: Better Home Cooking Through Science

Get the Book

Do you Agree?


Leigh C. April 20, 2016
I do whatever Kenji tells me. He is a master. And I love Zahav, the restaurant. I also have the cookbook which I love to read. I am about to try the brisket recipe but the hummus is the best. And now I am a tehina fanatic, buying only certain brands. In the end, I don't think these books are really comparable because one is a recipe book that's focus is a very specific kind of cooking from a very specific restaurant. Food Lab is much more general and technique oriented. I think both books would be wonderful additions to a cookbook collection but for different reasons.
Amy Z. March 18, 2016
Hi Phyllis, Amy here from Soom. thanks for ordering and so glad you enjoyed using Soom cooking through ZAHAV. amazing thought about the James Beard nom... he got one! love your critiques and commentary. and your kids sound awesome. cheers!
Greenstuff March 17, 2016
I carried it home in my backpack (it barely fit--it's a small, cityish backback), I made myself a martini. And then I re-read this "You will need a martini. Or a sherpa." Ha! Who knew I needed both.
Phyllis G. April 25, 2016
oh my goodness i laughed out loud!
Chiara B. March 14, 2016
First of all i really enjoyed reading your review. I like Zahav a lot because since I own this cookbook I improved my hummus game a lot and since it is one of my fav food on earth, it was pretty life changing. I agree that the styling and even the size of the book could have been different though. Questions: did you freeze the tehina cookie dough or the cooked cookies? I am planning a large tea time and it would be extremely helpful to know! Thanks.
Phyllis G. April 18, 2016
so sorry i didn't see these questions. i would recommend freezing the dough. but i froze them already baked and they were great too.
Rose L. March 12, 2016
My mentor Cecily Brownstone, who was food editor of Associated Press, taught me years ago never to be "a typewriter cook." She had to explain what that meant: It's someone who writes a recipe without testing it. I don't know if she was thinking 10 to 20 times but i'm sure she's smiling down from heaven.

This is an extraordinarily brilliant review--as brilliant as these two writers deserve. I have both books--love both of them--and would have had a real problem judging them against each other. Brava Phyllis.
Phyllis G. April 18, 2016
Thank you, Rose. This means so much to me. When I taught myself to cook 20 years ago, your book was my guide. I do hope to meet you someday.
Rose L. April 18, 2016
i'm sure it will happen and i sure hope so Phyllis!
Angie M. March 11, 2016
I totally agree! I have both books and love them for different reasons! However, Kenji is my hero!
Nikeisah March 11, 2016
Heard Kenji speak on The Freakonomics podcast for the book from the library. Yes it's a long extensive book but simple techniques and the science behind food can make an novice culinarian up their kitchen game!
Anne T. March 11, 2016
I have read Food Lab recipes on Serious Eats and have always found them too tiddly...your review inspired me to buy the book and learn more. Looking forward to your book Phyllis, will it by out by Christmas 2016?
Phyllis G. April 18, 2016
i don't know when my book is coming out. hopefully sometime in the next year or two. thank you for your support.
geneenb March 11, 2016
I loved this review and know why she is so successful at it. It made me want to buy her cookbook cause I know it's gonna be rad.
Elisa March 9, 2016
Great writing. And I agree 100%. Look forward to her cookbook .
Alex March 9, 2016
Now THAT'S a review!
MCWolfe March 6, 2016
You have gotten to the heart of my biggest complaint about recent cookbooks - nobody tests the recipes! I recently got a book by a local celeb chef that I had really looked forward to - love his restaurants and the book was gorgeous. I knew from the first recipe I tried that it was going to be a disaster and I wasn't wrong. If anyone had attempted the recipes as written even once they would have known how wrong they were. The Food Lab has already become one of my favorites because I've been reading Kenji's work since he worked for CI and I trust that everything he does has been tested and will work exactly as promised. And that Peruvian jalapeño sauce alone is worth the price of the book - seriously, we put it on everything!
Alana K. March 4, 2016
This is the best review I've ever read. Not only do I want to hug the crap out of Phyllis, Dash, and Bella, but I also feel the need to hop on Amazon rn and spend the next few days doing nothing but learning all the things from The Food Lab. Thank you for this.
Thea March 4, 2016
I loved this review! You're so right about the abysmal photography in the Food Lab. Still, the recipes and techniques are so spot-on. I love geek cooking.
Rhonda35 March 3, 2016
Enjoyed this review so much I read it three times.
Jodi March 3, 2016
Best review I have ever read. Love Phyllis Grant and Dash and Bella. Also LOVE The Food Lab and KL-Alt. That book is amazing. It's like going to cooking school for 35 bucks. And yes, I will try Zahav.
Morningside H. March 3, 2016
Phyllis, this is a stellar review. I loved reading it! You really went for it. Thanks for all the effort you and your kids put into testing these recipes. I own the Food Lab already but was on the fence about Zahav. I think I will pass on that one but I do want to say that his restaurant in Philadelphia is absolutely worth a detour. I had an amazing meal there. I love your blog/ instagram feed and look forward to reading your cookbook when it's available.
sara_ann March 3, 2016
Great review. I own Zahav and enjoy cooking from it. I haven't picked up Food Lab but like his column.
noons March 3, 2016
Great reviews! This is what Piglet is all about. But I loved my persimmon pickles.
JK March 2, 2016
This reads like a twitter feed.