Lobster

14 Best Lobster Recipes for Summertime Flavor Now

And no, they're not all lobster rolls.

February  8, 2022
Photo by James Ransom

Fun fact about me: I was obsessed with Red Lobster growing up. In fact, I spent at least three of my preteen birthdays there, scarfing down a basket of Cheddar Bay Biscuits and my very own one-pound lobster with unbridled glee.

Why? Lobster is the crown jewel of the ocean—and even though I was young when I had my first taste, I quickly realized that I was eating the good stuff. Lobster meat is sweet, tender, and has that light, ocean-fresh flavor. While the price tag might be a bit steep, it certainly makes any dinner (especially birthdays) feel like a special occasion. Nowadays, I can't get enough of lobster rolls and big seafood boils during the hotter months, but there are so many other ways to enjoy this popular crustacean throughout the season.

So I've rounded up 14 of our very best lobster recipes just in time for summer, from a chilled avocado soup to a spicy tomato spaghetti. There are a handful of our favorite lobster roll recipes in there, too, because any lobster-y list wouldn't be complete without at least a few of them.

Shopping for Lobster

If you’re purchasing lobster in the grocery store or fish market, you’ll find it three ways: chopped meat that’s been shelled and frozen, whole lobster tails (fresh or frozen), or live lobster, usually found in a giant tank. The frozen lobster meat is a great option for lobster rolls or lobster pasta, but if you are boiling whole lobsters, you’ll want to look for the most active crustaceans. The ones who are more active in the case are most likely fresher and will have more tender-tasting meat. Oh, and this is not a time to shop early. Pick them as close as you can to when you’re planning to cook them (ideally, same-day or better yet, within a few hours) so that their quality doesn’t start to deteriorate. Keep them covered with a damp towel; if lobsters dry out, they’ll die before they ever have the chance to be cooked and dunked in drawn butter.


Our Best Lobster Recipes

1. Jasper White’s World-Famous Lobster Rolls

These Genius-approved lobster rolls are famous for a reason: The lobster is steamed slowly and gently before getting tossed in a special tarragon mayonnaise. Oh, and you can't forget that fluffy, butter-toasted roll.

2. Lobster Diavolo

You won't find a better lobster-y recipe for ripe summer tomatoes than lobster diavolo, a classic Italian pasta that gets its kick from red pepper flakes or Calabrian chiles.

3. Dyers Island Lobster Hash

Simple potato hash with a fried egg gets taken up about a hundred or so notches when you bring sweet, rich lobster meat into the mix—perfect for breakfast or brunch the day after a big lobster boil.

4. Garganelli with Lobster & Caramelized Fennel Purée

This dish is all about taking a humble ingredient—fennel—and cooking it nice and slowly until it becomes something altogether luxurious, elegant, and delicious. The fresh lobster meat, white wine, and heavy cream don't hurt either.

5. Seafood Paella (Paella de Mariscos)

This Catalan-style paella calls on tons of smoky spices, herbs, and vegetables to create an earthy, fresh-tasting dish that has just the right amount of from-the-sea flavor thanks to cuttlefish, squid, mussels, clams, cod, and a lobster stock that makes it.

6. Brown Butter Lobster Caprese Salad

You probably know and love a traditional Caprese salad: juicy tomatoes, creamy mozzarella, and basil. But once you try it with nutty, brown butter lobster and crunchy raw corn, you'll never look back.

7. New England Lobster Rolls with Lemon Chive Mayonnaise

There's always going to be lobster roll lovers out there who like theirs with nothing but steamed lobster in a buttered, toasted bun—not a lick of mayo in sight. But the recipe author for this lobster roll likes to mix things up by bringing in a lemony mayo, chives, and a bit of crisp Boston lettuce.

8. Lobster Avocado Panini

If you've already had one too many lobster rolls this season (is that even possible?), give this avocado panini a shot—it's light, easy, and perfect for leftovers.

9. Creamy Lobster Risotto

For special-occasion summer dinners, it doesn't get better than this creamy lobster risotto. Think: Arborio rice cooked until perfectly al dente in broth, dry white wine, and juicy San Marzano tomatoes. A sprinkling of fresh parsley at the end adds just the right brightness.

10. Pappardelle with Corn, Lobster, Pancetta & Crème Fraîche

Sweet corn and lobster make a tasty duo in this silky pappardelle pasta, while salty pancetta and tangy crème fraîche bring a bit of balance.

11. Brown Butter Vinaigrette Lobster Buns

Take what you think you know about lobster rolls and throw it out the window. This version from Eventide Oyster Co. in Portland, Maine warms up the lobster in browned butter and stuffs it in a fluffy steamed bun.

12. Cold Avocado Soup with Lobster & Scallions

This chilled, ready-for-summer soup gets its smooth creaminess from avocados, broth, and a splash of cream, plus a little bit of smoky heat from chipotle and cayenne pepper.

13. Avocado Lobster Rolls With Crispy Shallots

If you’re not too keen on mayo-heavy lobster rolls, try this creamy variation: avocado dressing (made from puréed avocados, garlic, and lemon juice) for a zippy dressing that beautifully complements the lobster’s sweet flavor and tender meat.

14. Flip-Side Lobster Lettuce Wraps

This is the most literal definition of a lobster salad, in which cold lobster meat tossed with mayonnaise, lemon juice, and celery is tucked into bibb lettuce “cups.” It’s the perfect light lunch or crowd-friendly starter to dinner after a day lounging in a cushioned chair poolside with a cocktail in hand. Sounds nice, right?

What's your favorite lobster recipe? Tell us in the comments below!

This post was updated in February 2022 to include additional recommendations from our editors. All products are independently selected by our editors, and Food52 may earn an affiliate commission.

See what other Food52 readers are saying.

  • HalfPint
    HalfPint
  • Naomi Counides
    Naomi Counides
Erin Alexander is the Brand Partnerships Editor at Food52, covering pop culture, travel, foods of the internet, and all things #sponsored. Formerly at Men’s Journal, Men’s Fitness, Us Weekly, and Hearst, she currently lives in New York City.

3 Comments

HalfPint July 8, 2019
You need more Asian recipes for lobster. Asians LOVE lobster, especially us Viets ;)

My favorite is a rice noodle (bun) bowl that my mother always made with lobster. This is the basic blueprint:

Rice vermicelli, cooked tender but not mushy and not al dente either.
Picked lobster meat, torn into small bite-sized chunks or shreds. And the green stuff and roe if you're up for it (there are health concerns as of late).
Julienned cucumbers
Juienned mint
Bean sprouts and/or shredded lettuce
nuoc cham (that ubiquitous Viet dipping sauce)
fresh squeezed coconut milk (in a pinch, a good canned or powdered coconut milk)

Assembly per person: Put a serving of vermicelli into a bowl. Top with lobster, then vegetables & herb, then drizzle generously with nuoc cham and a lighter drizzle of the coconut milk. Toss with chopsticks and dig in. This was my mothers method for stretching 2 larger lobsters to feel a family of 7.
 
HalfPint July 8, 2019
*feed, not feel. ;)
 
Naomi C. July 8, 2019
Amusing..4 of the 12.
25% are sandwiches.