The Piglet2010 / Quarterfinal Round, 2010



Eugenia Bone

Get the Book

I Loved, I Lost, I Made Spaghetti

I Loved, I Lost, I Made Spaghetti

Giulia Melucci

Get the Book

Judged by: Elise Bauer

Elise Bauer is the founder of Formerly a Silicon Valley marketing exec, she now spends her days cooking and blogging about it. She makes her own elderberry jelly. She once seduced a man with a peach.

The Judgment

Talk about apples and oranges. In one corner we have Well-Preserved, essentially a book about canning or preserving fish, meat, seasonal fruits and vegetables, and all the wonderful things you can make with what you preserve, and on the other side of the ring, I Loved, I Lost, I Made Spaghetti, a memoir of broken relationships, tied together with recipes.

Let's start with the spaghetti. Giulia Melucci has done it. She's gone ahead and fulfilled every dating single girl's fantasy who has suffered through boyfriends that should have come with warning labels tattooed to their foreheads, by writing a wickedly vengeful tell-all about these yo-yos. Her one anchor of sanity through the storms of her lost loves is her cooking. Giulia loves to cook, and she's pretty good at it. She woos men with halibut, survives dating droughts with "no nookie gnocchi," cooks farfalle for dates, and makes F-You cupcakes when things invariably come to a crashing end.

Every chapter details a different relationship, and the food that went with it. The chapters (and relationships) start out hopeful, each one a new possibility. But the signs of impending disaster are usually there, even early on, and as someone who has been-there-done-that, half the time I just wanted to take Guilia by the shoulders and shake her -- "NOOOOO, RUN, THIS GUY IS NOT FOR YOU" -- while reading, watching, in frustrating fascination as Guilia throws herself at men that don't deserve her. But just as I want to put down the book because it's all too hopeless, up pops a recipe, and a pretty darn good looking recipe at that.  

Guilia's next book should be a cookbook, really. Every recipe I made from her book was outstanding, and food is so much more life affirming and fun than relationship ruins. The "Unforgettable Halibut," baked with caramelized onions, honey, vinegar, currants, and mint? Delicious. "First Date Butterflies" and "Lachlan's Farfalle with Zucchini and Egg" are two of the easiest and best pasta recipes I've ever made. And the chocolate bourbon frosting on her "F-You Cupcakes"? I was eating it with a spoon. I Loved, I Lost, I Made Spaghetti is worth getting if just for the recipes.

Now on to Well-Preserved. Is canning the new black? If so, Eugenia Bone's Well-Preserved is certainly well timed. The book covers the basics of water bath and pressure canning, freezing, and curing through salt. For those of us who are used to making jams and jellies, the idea of branching out beyond sugared fruits into vegetables and meat can be intimidating (can you say botulism?). But Eugenia soothes our anxiety by carefully walking us through the steps of how to preserve food safely, including how and when to use a pressure canner, and when a simple water bath is sufficient.

Each chapter is a new preserved food item, followed by creative recipes of what you can make with it. There's a seasonal focus -- useful, since what one would normally want to preserve is the bounty of the season. One puzzling omission is the lack of any discussion of the role of sugar as a preserving agent (at concentrations found in jams and jellies, sugar literally sucks the moisture out of bacteria, making it impossible for them to survive). But most of the book is focused on all the things you can preserve other than jams and jellies, such as tomato sauce, pickled asparagus, canned tuna, sauerkraut, tomatillo sauce, smoked chicken, bacon, gravlax, etc.

I made four recipes from Well-Preserved, each excellent.  The olive tapenade couldn't have been easier and made a lovely sauce for the recipe that followed of sautéed chicken thighs. I've roasted red bell peppers plenty of times before, but never thought to can them in a marinade, and now because of Eugenia can do so with confidence. Her chicken with sausages and marinated red bell peppers is rich and satisfying.  

So, which one of these titles gets the nod to the next level? Although I loved many of the recipes in I Loved, I Lost, I Made Spaghetti, the story around it ultimately wore me out. The winner of this round is Well-Preserved, which although not nearly as titillating as Spaghetti, is thoughtfully written, has inspirational recipes, and encourages all of us to try our hand at something new.

And the winner is…



Get the Book

Do you Agree?


Blissful B. March 27, 2011
I realize Melucci's book didn't win this round, but the spotlighted First Date Butterflies recipe definitely caught my eye. I made it tonight & as I was eating, I kept thinking, "How can a dish this simple be so incredibly good?" It's a new favorite, and inspired me to buy the book. Thanks Giulia for writing it, and Elise & Food52 for spotlighting it.
MrsWheelbarrow October 26, 2009
Since last Spring, I've cooked my way through Well Preserved, from front to back. Ms Bone took this life-long home-canner on new adventures. The tuna is out of this world delicious, and the duxelles are now a staple in my refrigerator. This weekend, I took on BACON, and with Eugenia at my side, I felt confident I would be delighted with the results. PS I also read and cooked plenty from I Loved, I Lost... !
eatboutique October 26, 2009
I just adore Eugenia's book. I've used it 5 times and only had it a few weeks. Yay - very excited for this book to move on!