The Piglet2015 / First Round, 2015

Sponsored By Squarespace
Flavor Flours vs. Baking Chez Moi

Flavor Flours

Alice Medrich

Get the Book

Baking Chez Moi

Dorie Greenspan

Get the Book

Judged by: Rosie Schaap

Rosie Schaap is the author of the memoir Drinking With Men. The drink columnist for The New York Times Magazine and a contributor to This American Life, she has also written for Bon Appétit, Lucky Peach, Marie Claire, Saveur, Travel + Leisure, and many essay anthologies. A working bartender, Schaap is currently writing a book about whiskey.

The Judgment

It has become tiresome to hear people say, “I don’t like sweets,” and frankly, I call bullshit on it. Who doesn’t like sweets? At least when they’re delicious sweets? It's likewise become tiresome to hear people say, “I like cooking, not baking.” I’m tired of it too, but I’m going to go ahead and say it. 

Because with the former, I can confidently improvise; I can be less than precise; I can have fun. But the exacting rigors of the latter stand in direct opposition to my indolence, and quite honestly make me nervous. Baking always struck me as cooking for math majors, not for English literature majors who focused on Romantic poetry. I can make a creditable olive oil cake, indisputably excellent buttermilk biscuits, and an honest, satisfactory cobbler. That’s about the extent of my baking repertoire. Normally, when I throw a dinner party, dessert is cheese and fruit and chocolate. And that’s how I like it. Listen, I love good sweets and other baked goods, unashamedly, and I certainly wouldn’t turn down a beribboned box of éclairs or a freshly baked, lovingly latticed pie -- but I don’t want to make them myself.

So when Food52 sent me two godforsaken baking-centric books to judge for the Piglet, my immediate impulse was to chuck them out the window. But I’d made a commitment -- and I like to think I’m no whiner -- so with a stiff upper lip and just a little rage and resentment burning within me, I dove into Dorie Greenspan’s Baking Chez Moi and Alice Medrich’s Flavor Flours

You know what? 

There’s nothing godforsaken about either of these books. They’re both great. Even if they are about -- bah! -- baking.

Greenspan and Medrich are both total, time-tested pros: They’re sure-footed, experienced, and authoritative cooks and writers, who also happen to be excellent teachers. And that’s what I want most from cookbooks: To be taught, clearly and expertly, so that I fully comprehend the lessons and feel certain that I can take on the recipes myself, no matter how advanced.

And a significant part of Greenspan’s mission with Baking Chez Moi is to assuage fears about what is often (and not entirely wrongly) considered the formidable fussiness of French baking. She makes this abundantly clear with a spirited salvo in the introduction: “Here’s what I know: Real French people don’t bake! At least they don’t bake anything complicated, finicky, tricky or unreliable…When the French bake at home, they bake for love, for the people they care about most and for the joy of making them happy.”

Who could argue with that? Dorie Greenspan’s prose is as warm as a galette straight out of the oven; I could almost feel her encouraging presence with me in the kitchen as I cooked. I could picture her there by my side, rooting through my pantry for those vanilla beans lurking somewhere in the back, handing me a whisk, then helping with the dishes. I could easily imagine her saying out loud exactly what she writes in her introduction to a recipe for Lavender White Chocolate Pots de Crème: “There’s something so Winnie-The-Pooh about pots de crème, and something so utterly grown-up and sophisticated too,” and I could imagine myself nodding and smiling in delighted agreement. And if something goes wrong -- a soufflé doesn’t rise, a tart comes out less glossy than you’d hoped -- she’d have a funny tale to tell about the time, long ago, when she messed it up too. I might not believe she ever messed anything up -- she’s Dorie Greenspan, after all -- but I’d be grateful for the soothing, sweetly comic story anyway.

I thought about making those pots de crème, but I’d already decided to test one of the less complicated-sounding cakes from each book (I like cake), and from Greenspan’s I went with the Saint-Pierre Poppy Seed Cake. I chose it partly because I happened to have a stack of clementines on hand (they’re among my favorite things about winter), and a bag of poppyseeds, and the thought of these flavors together was impossible to resist. 

But I also chose it because Greenspan’s introductions to her recipes are frequently -- as with the pots de crème prologue -- deeply alluring narratives, and I particularly appreciated the one attached to this cake, in which a Frenchman beseeches her (“with a twinkle,” no less) to make it. It's a good cake, and I’d make it again -- I liked its texture and its just-right-not-too-sweetness, but I expected fuller flavor from it. Next time I’d take Greenspan’s advice to those who’d “like to pump up the flavor” and add a tiny bit of orange oil. I’d also mind her counsel, next time around, about the freshness and quality of the poppyseeds: Mine had not been stored, as she advises, in an airtight container in the freezer. They’d likely languished in a cabinet for a year or more. But the instructions were lucid and easy to follow, and it was easy to see why monsieur had requested she make the cake. The recipe delivered on the promise of the alluring introduction.

From Flavor Flours, I tried out the Carrot Spice Cake with Cream Cheese Frosting. Carrot cake, at least a more conventional version, has long been part of my limited baking repertoire. I should also disclose here that I’m a shameless and unreconstructed hippie -- I was cooking pots of quinoa for Deadheads in a cabin in the Santa Cruz mountains decades before any self-respecting non-vegan restaurant would have put it on a menu -- so it obviously follows that carrot cake is one of my favorite foods. I’m sure that in my life I’ve tasted about a hundred different versions of it, and made at least a dozen. And I want to tell you that Medrich’s, made with rice flour and oat flour, is the best I’ve ever made, the best I’ve ever eaten, just the best: moist but solidly constructed, intensely fragrant, and full-flavored.

The book is sensibly organized according to the flours that dominate the recipes in each chapter: Rice, Oat, Corn, Buckwheat, Chestnut, Teff, Sorghum, and Nut, and Medrich makes strong cases for all the ingredients she discusses -- brown rice flour lends a lovely toasty and caramel quality to much that it touches, sponges benefit from chestnut flour’s smoothness, and sorghum’s slight sweetness makes it a good companion to other sweet flavors we associate with the cooking of the American South. She acknowledges that working with some of these flours requires patience and adaptation. She can sound stern at turns -- “Pay close attention to the mixing instructions; your opinions about buckwheat depend on it.” -- but, as with all good and exacting teachers who truly want their students to learn, you know it’s for your own good. (Flavor Flours often felt to me like taking a class grudgingly, just to fulfill a requirement, and winding up loving it.)

Medrich’s book, for all of its elegance and sophistication, still spoke to my hippie self. For all my unabashed earthy-crunchiness, and despite my early adoption of quinoa, I hardly knew what to do with any of these grains before I cracked open Flavor Flours. And I didn’t particularly think I wanted to know, mostly out of a grudging suspicion that they’re both too trendy and too much the domain of anti-wheat militants. But I never felt that Medrich was catering to the trendy or the intolerant; rather, she’s honoring and creatively engaging the distinctive qualities of less familiar grains. Her writing may not share the friendly intimacy of Greenspan’s, but there are times in the kitchen when I don’t so much need a friend as I need someone to tell me exactly what to do and precisely what I need to know. 

I’m tempted to call a draw here, but that’s not what I’ve been tasked to do, even if I have come to consider the two books equals in terms of excellence. Baking Chez Moi is probably the most user-friendly approach to French baking I’ve ever encountered. But much within it still felt familiar, if cast in less intimidating terms. Greenspan and Medrich are both great teachers. But ultimately I had to pick Flavor Flours as the winner, because it did something that books don’t do very often: It changed my mind. I’d never even considered using sorghum or teff flours before, and admit, with mild shame, to skepticism about most things gluten-free. (Medrich doesn’t force that issue at all here, and lets the flours reveal their own virtues in themselves.) Now? I know for sure I’ll never make a carrot cake with wheat flour again.

And the winner is…

Flavor Flours

Flavor Flours

Get the Book

Do you Agree?


HeatherM March 5, 2015
What a thoughtful review! Thank you.
Ileana M. March 2, 2015
I think is the best review yet!
Alice M. March 1, 2015
Thank you Rosie.I am thrilled and honored that Flavor Flours will go to the next round. Dorie inspires me always, as a consummate professional, beautiful writer, and lovely human being. I remain a great fan.
mainecook61 February 28, 2015
Cookbooks come and cookbooks go, like any fashion. It sometimes seems that every one that's "destined to become a classic" disappears from view in a few years time. I don't own either of the ones reviewed above, although based on her "buckwheat thumbprint cookies with cherry preserves" that appeared not long ago on this site, I wouldn't buy the Medrich, since I am assuming that that recipe (shudder) came from the new book. Just four years ago, another book that deals with all kinds of different flours, Kim Boyce's Good to the Grain, won the Piglet. I bought it then and have found it to be a wonderful book, with interesting, well-written, delicious recipes. She has a whole grain flour mix (whole wheat, oat, millet, rye, barley) that I use constantly, subbing it in (in part) in recipes that call for all white flour. If you're interested in using different flours (Boyce has chapters for the flours I mentioned, plus amaranth, buckwheat, corm, kamut, quinoa, spelt, and teff) take a look at this one, too.
Mary D. February 28, 2015
So glad Flavor Flours won - I'm a professional baker and it has given me so much inspiration.
QueenSashy February 28, 2015
Oh my, this was a tough draw. It feels a little bit like seeing Djokovic and Federer play in the first round of US Open...
chels February 28, 2015
This looked like the most difficult decision in the competition so far! I love both authors very much, but I'm happy that Alice won!
carolcamille February 28, 2015
What a superb review and I agree with the choice. Both books are destined to be classics, but Alice Medrich takes you on an unknown path and makes you happy to learn about these wonderful unknown grains!
Victoria C. February 28, 2015
Another great review. My opinion stands - these are the best Piglet reviews ever. Rosie Schaap, the brilliant writer who impossibly turned me on to Brandy Alexanders this cold, cold winter, had a difficult row to hoe choosing between these two cookbook authors, both of whom I respect and whose recipes I use. The best cake in my repertoire is Alice Medrich's Almond Cake with a Crunchy Crust from her impeccable Pure Dessert, made the day before I plan to serve it. Its texture, scent, and flavor make it my favorite cake ever. But Dorie Greenspan's French Apple Cake is no slouch of a recipe and delicious in a homespun kind of way, and I have all the gear ready to make the cannelé in Baking Chez Moi. I have been debating about getting Flavor Flours or not, and this pushed me over the edge. Even though I resolved to only buy the winner of the Piglet this year (if I already didn't have it), I'm breaking that promise to myself and getting Flavor Flours today.
mrslarkin February 28, 2015
What a thorough and thoughtful review! Thank you, Rosie.

I had the pleasure and great fortune to meet Dorie in person at one of her book signings. She is everything you've heard about - kind, gracious, helpful, and she gives the best hugs - pretty much the same thing her cookbooks deliver.

I don't have many Alice Medrich cookbooks, but I will rectify that very soon!
rosalind5 February 28, 2015
Oh! Baking Chez Moi is so wonderful. I'm sure Flavor Flours is too, but I have *loved* cooking from BCM. The custardy apple squares, granola cake, granola bars, brown butter vanilla cake. It's been a joy.
Alexandra H. February 27, 2015
Wonderful review! This was indeed a difficult decision! I love, love, love Dorie and have every single book she has written! I also admire Alice's work and have her chocolate tome, her Craftsy class, and this new flour book. Both are exceptional teachers.
familydinners February 27, 2015
Now I really want to get Flavor Flours to bake for my GF friends.
cheesypennies February 27, 2015
I think this was definitely the toughest match up in the tournament. As an unabashed baker (yes, I did study engineering in college!) and fan and collector of both authors' books, I tip my hat to this excellent reviewer. I also think that with Flavor Flours, the author is charting new ground relative to her other books, which made me more interested in adding that book to my shelf, and allowing myself the comfort of cooking old favorites from the other.
Tamara B. February 27, 2015
Baking Chez Moi seems more like my kinda cook book
Vicki February 27, 2015
I love to bake, especially breads, cookies and desserts. I'm always intrigued by something new to try and have had some excellent results with gluten free recipes. I have made recipes by both of these distinguished authors so purchasing both books is an easy choice!
M.Kurtzman February 27, 2015
I've baked and cooked recipes from both of these books,and am happy not to have to choose. A Tip of the hat to Alice Medrich for doing the footwork in exploring other grains,and crafting delicious recipes with them. The coconut chiffon cake gets two spins and a snap.
Megan February 27, 2015
I have a lot of cookbooks, but only one or two specific to baking. I am a cooking person rather than a baking person, I have to say! But yes, I love to EAT baked goods. Now I have two cookbooks to add to my list. I can see how this was a difficult choice. I am excited to read Flavor Flours. I've thought of non-wheat flours as (often frustrating) substitutes for wheat flour and it is exciting to think of them as ingredients in their own right. Also over Christmas I had the absolute most delicious, tender, and moist bundt cake I've ever had and it was from a gluten-free bakery. Made me more curious about these non-wheat flours...
Thank you for a great a review!
Joannagug February 27, 2015
Great discussion! I have several books from each author, so I AM a fan of both. But I have limited experience with the variety flours, so it would be fun to won Medrich's book. Thanks!
braiseandbutter February 27, 2015
I don't own Flavor Flours yet but I've tried a few of the recipes and they've both been outstanding. Congratulations!