Holiday Entertaining

The Best [Any Occasion Whatsoever] Cheesy, Bready Appetizer

November 28, 2016

When we made caramelized onion and Gruyère-stuffed pull-apart bread in the office (inspired by French onion soup and this jaw-dropping Kitchn tutorial), there was not one person who was not thrilled about it.

"I'm making this for Christmas!" said Allison.
"I'm making this for New Year's!" said Kenzi.
"I'm making this for dinner tonight!" said I.

When this came out of the oven, we became wild animals. Photo by Mark Weinberg

It's like garlic bread but better. Because it's solved all of garlic bread's problems.

  • Obviously the best part of garlic bread is the garlic- and butter-soaked squishiness towards the loaf's center. In this bread, you expose the maximum amount of the doughy innards, thereby creating more surface area onto which cheese can melt and more room to tuck away "goodies" like caramelized onions, bacon, and sautéed kale (see below for more ideas).

  • With garlic bread, you can get great (soaked, flavorful) or mediocre (dry, sharp) slices. Here, there's more control (and smaller pieces = less commitment): Pull out a tiny bread column, then another, and another. Select whether you want a doughy or crusty piece, one that's been drowned in toppings or one that's got less going on.

  • It's communal and forces interaction. Your guests/family members will have to talk (and touch) whilst ripping a loaf of bread to shreds.

  • It releases all of the stress of the holiday season through purely animalistic ripping and tearing.

Convinced yet?

Shop the Story

But you probably didn't even need those reasons. Just look at this:

Is it a giant baked potato? Photo by Mark Weinberg

Here's how to make it:

1) Crosshatch your bread.

Grab a loaf of bread from your nearest bakery (or grocery store—this is a technique that's going to make even the not-best bread taste very, very good).

Join The Conversation

Top Comment:
“Our favorite was with crispy bacon, green onions, garlic and smoked gouda! serve with a salad and dinner is DONE! This is sooo good. Thanks for the reminder--Time to do it again during this holiday season. (I did comment on this once before, I wonder where my comment went?)”
— judy

This can be a sourdough boule, a ciabatta, or a whole-grain loaf. Keep in mind that a strong-flavored loaf might compete with your add-ins if you don't choose the flavors wisely. If the bread has its own flavorings (raisins? nuts? olives?) that will dictate what you top it with.

Starting from one side, use a serrated knife to slice the loaf practically all the way through, then move a little over and slice again. Then to the same thing the other way. Your goal is to cross-hatch the entire thing without slicing through the bottom. But the closer you get to the loaf's hard base, the less detritus you'll be left with in the end.

Slice one way, then the other. Don't cut all the way through. Photo by Mark Weinberg, Mark Weinberg

2) Tuck a lot of stuff into it.

When thinking about toppings, pick a recipe or a dish as inspiration. We went with French onion soup, but you could use a nacho recipe you love, a great pizza, or your favorite sandwich.

Onions cooked with apple cider vinegar and maple syrup until jammy worked well, as would cooked and chopped bacon or sausage, or any number of sautéed vegetables, like mushrooms, greens, or leeks. Add sun-dried tomatoes or chopped roasted red peppers, roughly chopped olives or cooked black beans. Pine nuts and roasted garlic? Great idea!

Or, go totally rogue and play off Alice Medrich's Grilled Chocolate Sandwiches, using dark chocolate chunks, sea salt, and plenty of olive oil.

With the exception the the cheese (we're getting to that part!), be sure to add toppings in their complete and/or cooked form: While whatever ingredients near the top of the loaf might crisp up, raw mushrooms will not magically roast and bacon will not magically sizzle.

And, whatever toppings you use, be sure not to just plop them on the bread, but to take care to tuck them into the little bread crevices. That's the only way the bread close to the base will get its fair share of flavor.

Onions, plopped (left) and tucked (right). Photo by Mark Weinberg, Mark Weinberg

And then you'll want cheese, obviously. We chose Gruyère for our French onion soup-inspired bread, but any number of melty cheeses would work well: mozzarella, Monterey Jack, or cheddar, for example. You want something that is going to melt into beautiful strands of goo: It makes the pulling-apart more fun.

You could supplement with non-melty cheeses (like Parmesan, pecorino, feta, or soft or crumbly goat cheese), but don't use any cheeses that are watery or might react weirdly to high temperatures (ricotta, we're looking at you).

Wrong amount of cheese (left); right amount of cheese (right). Photo by Mark Weinberg, Mark Weinberg

3) Season it.

We seasoned our bread simply, with crushed red pepper flakes, but you could be more ambitious: za'atar, dukkah, curry powder, grainy mustard, Sriracha, pickled red onions.

You'll also want to add another drizzle of liquid to baste the bread and make sure it doesn't dry out. We used good old olive oil, but you could use melted butter, pesto, a bit of vegetable broth or chicken stock, harissa mixed with olive oil, or even Everything Bagel in Olive Oil.

Since our caramelized onions were pretty gooey, we didn't have to add so much liquid. Don't go overboard (just use a tablespoon or two) to avoid bread sog.

Olive oil and red pepper flakes: a subtle but important change. Photo by Mark Weinberg

4) Bake it.

Wrap the loaf of bread in foil like the giant baked potato it resembles.

See ya later, big guy! Photo by Mark Weinberg, Mark Weinberg

Lay it on a baking sheet, then send it into a 350° F oven for 20 minutes. Adieu for now!

Carefully unwrap the loaf and put it back in the oven for 10 minutes to crisp up its top and make the cheese bubble. Keep a close eye on the bread during this final bake: Toppings near the surface have a tendency to burn.

Before and after the final 10-minute bake. Photo by Mark Weinberg, Mark Weinberg

5) Go at it.

Here, you need no advice. Give the bread carcass—the bottom part of the loaf that you did not cut through all of the way—to someone you love.

One more time!

This article originally appeared on December 28, 2015. We're re-running it because it's holiday season, which means parties (and lots of appetizers).

See what other Food52 readers are saying.

  • anne reiswerg
    anne reiswerg
  • judy
  • Andrew Wilson
    Andrew Wilson
  • kendraaronson
  • Francesca
I used to work at Food52. I'm probably the person who picked all of the cookie dough out of the cookie dough ice cream.


anne R. December 3, 2017
Question: Do i tuck garlic butter in first? Then cheese and onions? Am i over thinking this??
Sarah J. December 3, 2017
I would tuck in cheese and onions, then pour melted garlic-butter over top!
judy December 1, 2017
I've done this a couple of times. Totally excellent. Our favorite was with crispy bacon, green onions, garlic and smoked gouda! serve with a salad and dinner is DONE! This is sooo good. Thanks for the reminder--Time to do it again during this holiday season. (I did comment on this once before, I wonder where my comment went?)
Andrew W. October 20, 2017
This looks so good. I'm betting that I can swap in celery flake and poultry seasoning to make a Thanksgiving "stuffing" without dirtying another casserole.
kendraaronson December 28, 2016
Excuse me while I mop up my drool—can't wait to make this on New Year's Eve to soak up the booze in my belly :)
Francesca April 15, 2016
I saw this bread on Bright Side recently on facebook. It does look easy and the cheese can be varied to taste too., but I must have lots of garlic.
Hope April 15, 2016
I've seen this recipe pinned so much it resembles Alpine lace swiss, but barely thought much more about it. Meh. However, the way you present it kicks my culinary muse in the butt to be creative. Thank you for making me think....apples sauteed in cardamom tucked beneath Wisconsin cheddar. And I'm thinking a nice shell of butter, cinnamon, sugar, smoky paprika & pecans...autumnal mouthgasm. Damn. Drooled on my phone.
Phillis M. April 15, 2016
This looks awesome. Am going to make it for a "beer and bread" bash at my daughter's next week. I do wish you had a printable version however. It would be a bib help
NotTooSweet December 30, 2015
NEED TO MAKE THIS NOW! I've gotta get some bread and try this as soon as possible. New Year's Day - football and this bread. Can't wait!
Alexandra S. December 28, 2015
omg looks amazing. Happy happy New Year, Sarah! Making for fam (bro in from CA, sister, 3 parents, aunt, lots of kiddies) tomorrow, Dec 29th, because we are all sick of cooking/dishes and have wiped out nearly all leftovers. Can't wait.
Kim M. December 28, 2015
This is brilliant!
kimikoftokyo December 28, 2015
I'm on my way to whole foods now to buy stuff. I'm making this tonight. With sparkling cider to match ?