Pie

The Most Popular Thanksgiving Recipes, By State

November  7, 2017

Our friends at Hayneedle, a leading online retailer of indoor and outdoor home furnishings and décor, have buried their noses deep in data. They dug through Google Trends to find the most-searched Thanksgiving recipes in every state. What they’ve discovered may be useful as you begin to plan your turkey day menu.

Photo by Hayneedle

It turns out, the most popular recipes tend to lean sweet. Out of all the Thanksgiving recipes, desserts came out on top. Surprisingly, the famous turkey was nowhere to be seen. Instead, pumpkin pie was the most searched recipe—it topped the list in 26 states. The northwest, west coast, and some of the midwest proved to be the biggest fans of the fall favorite. Coming in second was the sweet, sticky pecan pie. Southeastern states like Georgia, South Carolina and Lousiana were just three of the 12 states where the pecan reigned supreme. Third place fell to the always classic apple pie. Nine states were busy searching for this pie’s recipe.

Photo by Hayneedle

All in all, the results were pretty consistent. Expected even. But where there’s statistics, there’s always an outlier—or, in this case, three. Hawaii, Delaware, and Illinois bucked the trend; each state had their own most popular search term. In Hawaii, pumpkin crunch, a pumpkin cake topped with pecans, proved popular. Delaware, meanwhile, skewed savory—stuffing came out on top. Illinois seemed to favor sweet potatoes. What iteration exactly? We may never know.

Shop the Story

The results are culled from terms searched between 2011 and 2015. Hayneedle even went so far as to visualize the data on a handy map and pie chart for the more visually inclined. I definitely enjoy looking at the ways popular recipes orient themselves regionally. As a Texan myself, I can attest to the importance of good ol' pecan pie in the local diet.

Join The Conversation

Top Comment:
“Had to read this twice because pumpkin pie is not necessarily the top favorite to eat. Then readthe most googled recipe per state. I admit lately I've been searching for orange cranberry Bundt cake recipes. But it has nothing to do with Thanksgiving it just sounded like something I'd want to make. It's either most favorite part of the meal is the turkey and stuffing in this family. Happy Thanksgiving everyone happy eating! 🦃”
— BerryBaby
Comment

We're celebrating a special holiday sweepstakes in partnership with Hayneedle. Enter here for a chance to win everything you need to gift in style this year.

7 Comments

BerryBaby November 8, 2017
Had to read this twice because pumpkin pie is not necessarily the top favorite to eat. Then readthe most googled recipe per state. I admit lately I've been searching for orange cranberry Bundt cake recipes. But it has nothing to do with Thanksgiving it just sounded like something I'd want to make. It's either most favorite part of the meal is the turkey and stuffing in this family. Happy Thanksgiving everyone happy eating! 🦃
 
HalfPint November 7, 2017
Interesting...what is Pumpkin Crunch?
 
AntoniaJames November 7, 2017
See this: http://www.hawaiimagazine.com/content/how-make-hawaii-style-pumpkin-crunch-local-moms-recipe Who knew? It looks good! ;o)
 
Julie November 7, 2017
Pumpkin crunch is pretty similar to a pumpkin pie, but it has a crunchy layer on top. ...Think of it like an pumpkin pie flipped upside down. My mother's recipe also has wonderful candied bits of toffee strewn over the top.
 
HalfPint November 8, 2017
Oooo, that does look good and the ingredient lists sort of checks all the boxes for me ;) <br />Thanks AJ!
 
HalfPint November 8, 2017
@Julie, can you post your mother's recipe for pumpkin crunch? Please :)
 
AntoniaJames November 7, 2017
Also interesting, a broader search - looking at the most distinct recipes in each state . . . which provides quite a different picture. http://www.businessinsider.com/most-popular-thanksgiving-recipes-2016-11 ;o)