What to Do with an Overload of Peppers - Marinated Pepper Salad


What to Do with an Overload (or Not) of Peppers

September  5, 2014

It's the season of overflowing market bags, heavy CSA boxes, and gardens run amok. Alexandra Stafford of Alexandra Cooks is showing us how to store, prep, and make the most of the bounty, without wasting a scrap.

Today: How to store, prep, and make the most of the season's pepper crop, whether you have just a handful or you picked so many you should be called Peter Piper. Start with Yotam Ottolenghi's marinated pepper salad.

If only by the end of summer we as cooks and gardeners felt burdened by our pepper crop; found ourselves dumping our bounty on neighbors' front doors; bemoaned yet another dinner of chiles rellenos.

Shop the Story

Imagine if we faced a wealth of glossy -- red! -- peppers every time we walked out to those raised beds. If only so many of us were not still waiting for our green-fruit laden plants to show any signs of ripening. 

We can dream, but the good news is that Yotam Ottolenghi has come to the rescue. With just two peppers and a few other ingredients -- fresh basil, capers, mixed greens, and shaved Pecorino -- the master of vegetarian cooking has crafted a late-summer salad filled with texture and flavor. And despite the presence of a few strong characters (capers, Pecorino), the flavor of the peppers permeates every bite. 

More: Got a jar full of capers? Use them for a week's worth of dinners.

The trick is that the roasted peppers marinate for at least an hour in a mix of olive oil, balsamic, garlic, and thyme. During this time, the peppers not only absorb these flavors, but also infuse a smoky sweetness into the marinade, which ultimately becomes the dressing for the salad. 

These roasted peppers can be used in countless ways, most simply with a loaf of crusty bread and a wedge of cheese. But the salad -- made with nearly equal parts herbs to greens, and laced with slivers of red, pops of green, and stark white cheese shavings throughout -- is stunning. And (with or without a bumper crop of peppers) can be on your table tonight.  

To store your peppers, however many you have:

  • If your kitchen is cool enough, you can store unwashed peppers out of the fridge covered with a kitchen towel.
  • Do not store in plastic bags, which foster moisture development and cause peppers to spoil more quickly.
  • Peppers will keep for at least a week in the fridge, but, as with tomatoes, the cool temperature is not ideal for preserving their flavor. It's best to store them at room temperature and eat them within a few days.

To prep your peppers:

  • When slicing and seeding peppers, always be sure to wash your hands afterwards and be careful not to rub your eyes while you are working.
  • Peppers are often served raw. Crisp, fresh, colorful peppers, cut into slivers are a favorite on crudité platters. Cut out and discard the stem, seeds, and white membranes before slicing. Finely diced raw peppers add great texture and flavor to salsas (mango, pineapple, peach, etc.); sandwiches; and to pasta, potato, bean, and whole grain salads.

To cook your peppers: 

  • You can simply sauté them. Cut peppers in half, then remove the stem and seeds and discard them. Julienne or cut the flesh into small dice. Sautéed diced peppers pair nicely with onions, tomatoes, corn, eggplant, squash, capers, garlic, and herbs, and can be used as the foundation for soups, stews, and sauces. Add sautéed peppers to tacos and fajitas, sandwiches (vegetarian or sausage-laden), pizzas and pastasfrittatas and quichesbraises and tagines.  

  • There are lots of ways to roast peppers, and depending on how you do it, your resulting peppers will vary in texture. If you char the peppers quickly over an open flame (using a grill, stovetop, or broiler), the flesh of the peeled pepper will be firm and will taste smoky. If you roast the peppers at a more moderate temperature (as described in the Ottolenghi salad recipe below), the flesh of the peeled peppers will be softer, will taste sweeter, and the peppers will release more flavorful juices. You can roast peppers whole and seed them afterwards, or you can cut and seed them before roasting.

More: Turn your roasted red peppers into a sweet condiment.

  • Peppers can be roasted in the oven at a range of temperatures (375º F to 450º F), and the cooking time will vary depending on the temperature (20 to 40 minutes or so). They can be left whole, or they can be seeded and cut before roasting. Either way, rub them lightly with olive oil, place them in a single layer on a baking sheet, and roast them until they begin to soften and darken in spots. When the peppers are roasted whole, rotate them every so often to make sure they char evenly. Alternately, to char peppers over an open flame, place a whole pepper directly over the flame and cook, rotating every so often with tongs, so that the skin chars evenly. The process should take 10 to 15 minutes. Either way, once roasted, transfer them to a bowl, cover it with plastic wrap, and let them sit for at least 15 minutes. Rub the skins off the peppers and discard them (along with the seeds, if you haven't seeded them already). Save the juices! Never rinse the peppers to facilitate skin or seed removal -- you'll be washing away much of the flavor.

  • Poblanos or any long green chile (or any chile, really) can be roasted and stuffed with cheese and eggs and fried or baked into chiles rellenos.
  • Bell peppers (stem left intact, halved lengthwise or vertically, both parts briefly boiled) can be stuffed with meat or vegetables and baked with savory sauces or broths until the peppers are tender and the fillings are cooked through.
  • Peppers can be pickled or cooked into jam and confit.

Tell us: How do you love cooking with peppers?

Marinated Pepper Salad with Basil, Capers & Pecorino

Serves 2 as a starter

1 red bell pepper, quartered
1 yellow bell pepper, quartered
3 tablespoons olive oil
1 tablespoon balsamic vinegar
1 tablespoon water
1/2 teaspoon muscovado sugar (regular is fine)
2 thyme sprigs (optional)
1 garlic clove, thinly sliced (optional)
Black pepper to taste
2 tablespoons flat leaf parsley, leaves picked (optional)
2/3 cups basil leaves
1 cup watercress or arugula or mixed greens
2 ounces Pecorino, Parmigiano Reggiano, or Manchego, shaved
1 tablespoon drained capers

See the full recipe (and save and print it) here.

Photos by Alexandra Stafford

Order now

A New Way to Dinner, co-authored by Food52's founders Amanda Hesser and Merrill Stubbs, is an indispensable playbook for stress-free meal-planning (hint: cook foundational dishes on the weekend and mix and match ‘em through the week).

Order now

See what other Food52 readers are saying.

  • Susan
  • Michael Keshen
    Michael Keshen
  • Alexandra Stafford
    Alexandra Stafford
  • Weasel8
I write the blog alexandra's kitchen, a place for mostly simple, sometimes fussy, and always seasonal recipes. My cookbook, Bread Toast Crumbs is available everywhere books are sold.


Susan September 6, 2014
Yum! I'll set this aside for next summer. My sweet peppers hardly produced (our yo-yo weather discouraged them). The hot peppers have vowed to make up the difference. I pickled a bunch last weekend then this morning took the easy way out and threw today's harvest into the dehydrator. The house has a wonderful peppery aroma. :-)
Author Comment
Alexandra S. September 7, 2014
So fun! Next summer I want to try hot peppers. I am still dreaming about these blistered padron peppers my husband and I had at a tapas restaurant, and I keep reading about shishito peppers, but I can never find either at the market. It would be so much fun to have a supply of hot peppers on hand.

I am a completely novice gardener but from what I gather from friends, this wet summer has not been good for peppers and tomatoes. Every time I try to grow things, my appreciation for farmers grows. I wish I understood more!
Weasel8 September 7, 2014
I grew shishitos this year, and the bad weather didn't seem to affect them at all. They are pretty easy, and probably wouldn't disappoint, so I'd recommend them for beginners.
Author Comment
Alexandra S. September 7, 2014
Such great news. I went to my farmers' market this morning hoping (having not been in a few weeks) someone might have some shishitos, but once again, no luck. Definitely going to try growin shishitos next summer. Thanks!
Michael K. September 5, 2014
Great article! I absolutely love peppers and put them in pretty much everything. Didn't know about leaving at room temperature with a towel over them.
Author Comment
Alexandra S. September 7, 2014
Thanks, Michael! I only recently learned this, too. I was reading this book I've had for years, one that I often pull out this time of year, and I found that tip in the pepper chapter. The book is The San Francisco Ferry Plaza Farmers' Market Cookbook by Chistopher Hirsheimer (from Canal House) and Peggy Knickerbocker. I do still store peppers in the fridge when I know I am not going to use them in a few days, but since learning this tip, I try to cook my peppers within a few days of receiving them.