Dinner

55 Crock-Pot Recipes to Set & Forget

Because at the end of the day, comfort cooking will always mean comfort food.

by:
November 26, 2021
Photo by Rocky Luten. Food Stylist: Anna Billingskog. Prop Stylist: Amanda Widis.

A couple of years ago I wrote that I'd never throw out my Crock-Pot, a priceless, light blue checkered heirloom piece of scrap metal named Hal. Update: I still haven't. Despite all of the love letters I've written to the Instant Pot this year, I'm happy to report that Hal is alive and well, and sitting on my bookshelf as we speak.

Do I use him as often as my Instant Pot? Maybe not. But I do love him more. I love that he only has three options for me (Off, Low, and High), and that I can carry him under one arm. My Instant Pot may cook up a mean short rib, but it's heavy, ugly, and doesn't have a name—because no matter how many fancy appliances come into my life and sweep me off my feet, Hal the Crock-Pot will always be my bread and butter when it comes to slow-cooking.

I still take Hal off the shelf on occasion, when I've dirtied up the Instant Pot but haven't had time to run it through the dishwasher. Or when I’m feeding a crowd and need to make a lot of one thing, like meat or soup or stew. Or when I'm leaving the house for hours to go to work or run errands (there’s a lot to be said for setting your dinner ahead of time and knowing that you can come home to it, perfectly cooked).

Or when I'm cooking a delicate recipe, like my milk-poached chicken breasts, which requires the low, gentle heat of a slow cooker. (No matter what, I find that my Instant Pot, even at its lowest setting, runs just a bit hotter than Hal, whose loose-fitting lid means that steam can escape and flavors can reduce and concentrate.)

Whether you're Team Instant Pot or Team Hal Slow Cooker, there's a time and place for both. Here are the best slow-cooker recipes for when you're feeling the latter.


Soupy & Stewy

1. Tom Kha Gai

Though tom kha gai, a Thai coconut soup scented with lemongrass and lime leaves, is ordinarily a quick boil on the stovetop, in this case, a longer spell in the slow cooker makes for more succulent chicken thighs and a more aromatic broth.

2. Chicken Parmesan Soup

One of our oldest and most popular slow-cooker recipes, this soup holds all of the comforting, familiar flavors of the red-sauce classic.

3. Lentil & Root Veggie Soup

Two types of lentils—French green and black—add great bulk and depth to this hearty vegetable soup, which is easily veganized.

4. Beef Stroganoff

You could make a proper stroganoff in a skillet over high heat—or you could just dump all of the ingredients into your slow cooker, set it, and forget it.

5. Butter Chicken

A Food52 contest finalist, this slow-cooker take on butter chicken is bolstered up with sweet butternut squash and golden raisins.

6. Beef Stew

This Crock-Pot beef stew will warm your body, but it's the story behind it that will warm your soul.

7. Mediterranean Chicken Stew

This recipe is a community favorite for its bold, briny flavors and streamlined preparation. Serve with toasted flatbread for sopping up all that brothy goodness.

8. Creamy Chicken & Mint Curry

"When the mercury rises, I turn to my slow cooker," writes recipe author Rinku Bhattacharya. By layering flavors, she achieves a balanced dish that's both bright and fresh, as well as creamy and comforting.

9. Persian Lamb Stew

The slow cooker is ideal for big cuts of meat like this whole lamb shoulder—braised, shredded, and bejeweled with pomegranate seeds and fresh herbs.

10. Mom's New Orleans Red Beans & Rice

This is the dish that recipe author Katie Macdonald asks her mom for every year on her birthday. The “secret” ingredient that flavors each spoonful? Pickle juice. “It’s not the same if you don’t use it,” Macdonald's mom insists when describing the completely non-traditional addition. “It makes the entire dish.”

11. Vegan Crock-Pot Tomatillo Stew

To thicken this spicy mixture, you’ll smash the black and pinto beans with a potato masher (you could also give it a couple good whizzes with an immersion blender if that’s easier). Alternatively, if you prefer things brothier, simply leave it as is… but then you might have to call it a soup instead.

12. Crock-Pot Chicken Chicken Soup with Ginger and Fennel

Ditch the dill and carrots, and make this fennel-ginger number your new go-to chicken soup. Did we mention you can make it with a grocery store rotisserie chicken (or whatever leftover chicken you have on hand)? Ladle it over rice and top with spicy chili crisp to round out the meal.

13. Crock-Pot Pasta e Fagioli

Also known as “pasta fazool,” this carbs-on-carbs pasta and bean soup is a dream dinner for a cold night. Don’t forget a good crusty loaf of Italian bread to dunk in! This version is totally vegan, but if you wanted to toss in a smoked ham hock, be our guest. PS: need more vegetables? Wilt in half a bunch of your favorite greens before serving.


Meaty

14. Grape Jelly Meatballs

This classic retro slow-cooker sauce of grape jelly and chili sauce sounds weird, we know! But just wait until you try them—but if the sweet-spicy-sour sauce just isn’t your thing, the sheet-pan meatballs are a great appetizer on their own with your preferred dipping sauce, even jarred marinara (though you make them in the oven, not a Crock Pot!)

15. Brown Sugar & Balsamic–Glazed Pork Tenderloin

This recipe—the most cooked, most popular, and most loved in Food52 history—needs no introduction. With a side of polenta, mashed potatoes, or grains and a bright green vegetable, you'll be a happy camper.

16. Pork Shoulder With Brown Sugar & Balsamic Glaze

Inspired by the recipe above, I adapted the same sweet, sharp flavors for my preferred cut of pork: shoulder, which gets meltingly tender after a long bath in the slow-cooker. There's mustard powder in the glaze too, to balance the sweetness of the brown sugar and balsamic.

17. BBQ Ribs

Yes, you can (and should!) make baby back ribs in the slow cooker, which, according to recipe developer Grant Melton, "guarantees a fall-off-the-bone result without having to labor over a hot grill or smoker for hours." Melton also suggests cooking the ribs a day in advance, storing them in the fridge, and then giving them a quick cook on the grill or in the oven to warm through before serving. Plus, the (three-ingredient!) barbecue sauce couldn't be easier.

18. Shredded Beef Tacos

What better way to enjoy a hunk of beef chuck roast than to slow-cook, shred, and taco it? Don't forget the guacamole.

19. Citrus Pulled Pork Tacos

"I enjoy this dish because you can start in before you leave for work and your meat will be ready when you get home," writes recipe author Erin Powell. "The slaw takes minutes to assemble so you'll have dinner in no time!"

20. Pot Roast With Chickpea Salad

The real star here is the fresh chickpea salad, which brightens up the rich, hearty chuck roast. With this kind of meal, you don't even need to make sides. A weeknight dream!

21. Shredded Beef–Stuffed Chile Rellenos

A spice-rubbed roast gets slow-cooked until it's fall-apart tender, then stuffed into poblano peppers with cheese, tomato sauce, and more cheese and baked until bubbly.

22. Indian Spiced Lamb Chili

The results of this slow-cooker chili are much greater than the very low effort that goes into making it. "15 minutes of prep time and the slow cooker does the rest," says recipe developer Divya Kaur, who also suggests serving this Indian flavor-inspired chili with naan instead of the more common rice (but also, why not both!).

23. Italian Braised Pork

The porkiness of this slow-cooker pork is accented with crushed tomatoes, fennel seeds, and red wine—and tastes even better on a bed of polenta.

24. Pulled Pork With Sweet & Hard Cider

"If you don't have hard cider on hand, use an additional 12 ounces of regular sweet cider instead," advises recipe author WinnieAb.

25. Carolina Pulled Pork Barbecue

Smoked paprika adds just the right note to this slow-cooker pulled pork recipe. For those classic barbecue vibes, serve the pork on potato buns with coleslaw. Or build a bigger plate or with sides of slaw, mac and cheese, baked beans, and collards, plus a couple slices of white bread to sop up all the juices.

26. Banana Bread Sandwiches With Pulled Pork

"My friend and I stopped at the Caneel Bay Resort in St. John, USVI for lunch, not knowing that we were able to experience the best sandwich either of us had ever had," recipe author Joy Huang says. "I think it was that perfect balance of salty pulled pork and sweet banana bread plus the crunch from a red cabbage slaw. I tried to hunt down the recipe, but was unsuccessful, so here's what I came up with from memory."

27. Southern Choucroute

According to Merriam-Webster, choucroute is just another word for sauerkraut, which is "cabbage cut fine and fermented in a brine made of its own juice with salt." With juniper berries and caraway seeds, this is a flavorful and hearty side you'll want to make over and over.

28. Bacon, Corn & Cheese Frittata

Yep, that's a slow-cooker frittata—and yep, it's good! This one calls for bacon, corn, and pepper jack cheese, but you could use whatever you'd like. Kale, feta, and tomatoes? Yes! Sausage, onions, and peppers? Uh-huh! Leftover roasted vegetables? You bet!

29. Low-Country Shrimp Boil

When you think about it, it makes so much sense to cook up a shrimp boil in the slow cooker. What better way to ensure soft, tender shrimp and perfectly cooked corn and sausage?

30. Betty Wason's Basic Pot Roast

This Genius-approved pot roast has withstood the test of time, and multiple community members have recreated it successfully in the Crock-Pot. "Made this yesterday in my slow cooker and it was a dream," writes one reviewer.

31. Puerco Bravo (Braised Pork With Spicy Potatoes)

The late Pierino developed this slow-cooker recipe with inspiration from a Neapolitan-style ragu. But it's the quick and easy preparation that has made it a Food52 classic for many readers.


Chickeny

32. Crock-Pot Rotisserie Chicken

Did you know you can make a rotisserie chicken in your Crock-Pot? Oh heck yes! Rub down the bird with brown sugar, paprika, garlic powder, and lots of salt and pepper and plop in the slow-cooker. Though you’ll have to forgo crispy skin, you can pop the chicken under the broiler for a couple of minutes after slow-cooking for a bit more color.

33. Whole Poached Chicken

This Crock-Pot chicken recipe is a one-two punch: soft, perfectly poached meat and the most aromatic broth you'll ever taste. Shred the meat and use it in chicken salad, tacos, or your favorite chicken soup.

34. Bourbon BBQ Chicken Drumsticks

These sweet and sour meat lollipops get slow-cooked with a few spices, then slathered in a smoky barbecue sauce.

35. Chicken Breasts With Lemon, Sage & Milk

This is another recipe of mine, so allow me to explain myself: I'm convinced that it's the low heat here, along with the full tablespoon of salt (which almost quick-brines it), that contribute to a perfectly cooked boneless, skinless chicken breast.

36. Chicken Breasts With Creamy Mustard-Leek Sauce

Contrary to popular belief, you can cook chicken breasts in the slow cooker without them drying out to death. "This recipe produces tender, savory chicken that's also marinated overnight, which helps impart flavor," says recipe developer Josh Cohen. "The mustard-leek sauce is rich and flavorful, with a nice tinge of acidity from the mustard."

37. Chicken Thighs Confit

This recipe is so brilliant to me: We use our slow cookers for all of the obvious things (braises, stews, and soups). But why not for a huge vat of oil that confits meat? This means you can use the same method to confit vegetables (looking at you, eggplant, onions, tomatoes, garlic, carrots, and, well, anything!)

38. Honey-Garlic Chicken

This is, arguably, contributing writer Posie (Harwood) Brien's signature Food52 recipe. Harwood Brien likes to serving this recipe over greens mixed with rice or mashed sweet potatoes, but any of your favorite chicken sides will be delightful with the sticky sweet honey garlic sauce.

39. White Wine Chicken With Orzo

This recipe is a quick, comforting, modern spin on a very classic Greek dish called yiouvetsi. We love this one served with a lemony salad and lots of grated Greek Gruyère or kefalotyri cheese


Vegetarian

40. Greek Lentil Soup

Crock-Pot lentil soup, but make it Greek (that means you'll add tomato paste and cumin to the soup, ladle into bowls topped with plenty of creamy, salty feta).

41. Whole Squash With Spelt & Feta

Columnist Rebecca Firkser makes a case for 1) not peeling your squash and 2) not cutting it either (at least until after you've cooked it whole in the slow cooker). Because yes, you can plunk a whole squash in your Crock-Pot. Serve the tender vegetable with chewy grains like spelt or farro with a sweet and salty maple-miso dressing.

42. Black Beans

Super-simple black beans with onion, garlic, cumin, and a bit of orange are the ultimate set-and-forget recipe. Keep this one in your back pocket for tonight and every night, then serve with cooked grains, toast, eggs, and more.

43. Creamy Cauliflower & Sweet Potato Soup

The ingredient list here might look long, but the active cooking is bafflingly minimal. (You just need an immersion blender.)

44. Moroccan-Spiced Lentil Soup

This slow-cooker soup is absolutely loaded with veggies, spices, and legumes. We love this one over cooked brown rice or kamut.

45. Shiitake-Noodle Hot & Sour Soup

Sometimes you just need to slurp your dinner. Enter: this earthy dry shiitake-based broth, tangy with a good splash of vinegar. At the end, you'll stir in noodles (like lo mein, somen, or even spaghetti in a pinch) and top with a shower of sliced scallions.

46. Butternut Squash Shakshuka

Too often when we talk about Crock-Pot recipes, we leave out one of the most pleasurable meals of the week: brunch. With this recipe, we don't have to.

47. Borlotti Beans With Sweet & Sour Agrodolce Sauce

"This recipe has become one of my favorite ways to bridge the seasons," writes recipe author cookinginvictoria. It offers all of the delicious, warming comforts of a slow-braised dish for those chilly, gray days that are a part of springtime in Victoria, but it also includes some of the springtime bounty that I am starting to see in my garden, such as slightly spicy dandelions and arugula that say to me that warm, sunny weather will soon arrive."


Sweet

48. Easy Rice Pudding

The slow cooker is, contrary to popular belief, the perfect environment for rice to plump up into a sweet, spicy pudding. Recipe developer Eleni Vonissakou says this Greek rice pudding is "best enjoyed on a hot afternoon with a sprinkle of cinnamon."

49. Chocolate Chip Cookie

Oh yeah, you can absolutely make a big ol' cookie in a slow-cooker if you want. Firkser developed this recipe with one idea in mind: You can let it cool, then slice the giant cookie into bars, or serve it warm, scooped straight from the Crock-Pot, with a big scoop of ice cream.

50. Dulce de Leche Banana Icebox Cake

The "slow-cooker" aspect of this recipe isn't the cake itself; it's the homemade dulce de leche, which you can make from scratch in a Crock-Pot.

51. Cranberry Apple Crockpot Oatmeal

Community member Megan Olson shared this recipe, which is packed with protein (thanks, egg whites!) for a super-filling—and totally tasty—way to start the day.


Queso, Peanuts & 2 Mulled Things

52. Mom's 'Instant Party' Chile con Queso

You don't need me to tell you how to keep your queso warm. But with this recipe, you can (and should) start and finish your party in the Crock-Pot.

53. Salty Southern Boiled Peanuts

If you grew up in the South like I did, then you know the impulse to want to stop at the side of the road to buy a bag of hot, salted, boiled peanuts. Now you can make them at home in your Crock-Pot.

54. Honey-Pomegranate Mulled Wine

The loose-fitting lid on your slow cooker actually makes for better mulled wine—because there's room for the water (and alcohol) to escape, and for the flavors to mellow and develop and concentrate.

55. Delicately Fragrant Mulled Cider

Same story with cider. The slow cooker is an ideal vessel to store hot, comforting liquids to get you through the day.

What are your favorite Crock-Pot recipes? Let us know in the comments below.
The All for Farmers Market

We’ve joined forces with Tillamook to support All For Farmers—a coalition benefiting farmers across the nation—with a special market that gives back. Featuring Shop all-stars and a limited-edition Five Two apron, a portion of proceeds from every purchase supports American Farmland Trust’s Brighter Future Fund.

The All for Farmers Market

See what other Food52 readers are saying.

  • Cleowhiskey
    Cleowhiskey
  • Jenny
    Jenny
  • Nan G
    Nan G
  • Penny Hammack
    Penny Hammack
  • Urvashi Pitre
    Urvashi Pitre
Eric Kim was the Table for One columnist at Food52. He is currently working on his first cookbook, KOREAN AMERICAN, to be published by Clarkson Potter in 2022. His favorite writers are William Faulkner, John Steinbeck, and Ernest Hemingway, but his hero is Nigella Lawson. You can find his bylines at The New York Times, where he works now as a writer. Follow him on Twitter and Instagram at @ericjoonho.

5 Comments

Cleowhiskey November 26, 2021
I love your writing and recipes, Eric. Thank you for the instant lift and energy you bring to Food52 and the New York Times. I'm also proud that you're Korean.
 
Jenny February 9, 2020

If I were still cooking for partner and family, I suppose I would acquire an Instant pot. Being solo, and considerably older, I still use and love my little avocado Rival crockpot. A friend got it for a wedding present in the late '60's. She was going to throw it out, and I rescued it decades back. I often lose steam and enthusiasm for cooking by the end of the day...if I get "Puppy" (Rival was a popular dog food back in the day) cooking early on, I have dinner ready and done for a couple days. In the early '50's, Mom's stove had 3 burners and a "deep well cooker"...a built-in crockpot. She said my Grandmother had a heavy wood box, lined with straw. You heated bricks in an oven, placed them in the box with your bean pot, and it would cook in a similar fashion. Real "Old School" that!
 
Nan G. February 7, 2020
I've tried quite a few of these and they are all wonderful.
But my two favorites are the rotisserie chicken and the lamb shanks.
Tomorrow I'm making an Irish stew with a dark ale.
I probably use the slow cooker once a week.
 
Penny H. February 7, 2020
Nearly all of these sound yummy. I'll be using a lot more crock-pot liners. Please don't lecture me, I'm currently required to use a wheel chair and cleaning a crock-pot the environmental way would be almost impossible.
 
Urvashi P. January 16, 2020
So many delicious choices! Great roundup